Protectionism in a Depression--Posner

I have little to add to Becker's post, with which I agree. One does understand the support in Congress for adding "Buy American" provisions to the stimulus package now moving through Congress (the "American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009," as it is called). Apart from the usual interest-group pressures, the goal of the Act, or at least the stated goal (for besides the goal of stimulating the economy, there is the goal of advancing President Obama's long-term policy agenda at an opportune time, by grafting the agenda onto the stimulus), is to increase employment, and that means employment in the United States, obviously. If suppliers say of broadband equipment receive a government order and satisfy it by buying the equipment abroad, the increase in employment (if any) will take place in the country in which the equipment is bought. An appropriate solution to this dilemma is to focus the stimulus package on goods and services that are made in the United States. That is one more reason why, as some Republican senators are now urging, more of the stimulus money should go to construction, whether of roads or bridges or schools. True, some inputs into these products, such as steel for bridges, may come from abroad, but most are local, in particular of course labor--and there is a lot of unemployment in the construction industry. Indeed, government-financed construction, especially of transportation facilities, strikes me as the optimal Keynesian anti-depression program: the inputs are local, unemployment in the industry is great, our transportation infrastructure needs investment, improving it will confer external benefits (such as faster commuting and less wear and tear on vehicles), the costs can be eventually recovered, after the depression ends, in tolls and other user fees, and construction projects (especially repairs) can be commenced pretty quickly, especially if emphasis placed on funding state and local road and other infrastruture projects that have been interrupted or deferred by the states' depression-caused revenue shortfalls. On the topic of sending stimulus money abroad, I think the big foundations, such as the Gates foundation (the biggest), should be strongly urged to redirect their extensive foreign charity to the United States at this time of depression. I am not suggesting that his projects should "Buy American," in the sense of buying U.S. products to give to foreign recipients of his charities. The point is rather that charity should begin at home when home is suffering. The bailouts and stimulus and other expenditures, over and above our already huge budget deficits, aimed at getting us out of our economic doldrums as fast as possible, are going to increase the national debt significantly and by doing so impose heavy costs for years to come. The foundations in the aggregate spend many billions of dollars a year, and the substantial portion that goes to fight malaria in the Third World or promote agriculture or family planning there could be redirected--not all of course and not all at once, because the programs induce reliance on the part of the recipients--to the United States to help get us out of our economic predicament without assuming a staggering further burden of debt. I grant that poor countries may be harder hit by what is a global depression than the United States, but I consider Americans' obligations to be primarily to Americans rather than to the inhabitants, however worthy, of foreign countries. I am also inclined to think that charitable giving abroad is so closely entwined with the nation's foreign policy objectives that it should be regulated by the State Department rather than left entirely to private choice.

Comments

[Anonymous]

lzuXft Great. Now i can say thank you!

[Anonymous]

v7OGTG I want to say - thank you for this!

[Anonymous]

Hi all! The excellent site, has especially liked design. Thanks.
I am from Sri and too bad know English, tell me right I wrote the following sentence: "Online schools for grades can incorporate a mixture of online and traditional classroom learning or involve a purely online approach, as the following examples, taken from the setda study, show.Another way is to enroll in an online school that provides a systematized and organized training in internet marketing."

Thank you very much :D. Lewana.

[Anonymous]

Badly need your help. The bitterest tears shed over graves are for words left unsaid and deeds left undone.
I am from Lithuania and too bad know English, give please true I wrote the following sentence: "Silva vs griffin fight video anderson silva vs forrest griffin fight video."

THX :), Hartford ins.

[Anonymous]

I agree with Judge Posner that charily begins at home. At least from the standpoint of how taxpayer dollars should be distributed during an economic downturn. Some have made the argument that we have little to show for our overseas’ charity in the best or worst of times.
In terms of non-governmental charity, it’s no one’s business but the giver. medyum ; If Judge Posner believes private charity should be targeted to U.S. based recipients let him lead publically by example. I don’t believe it’s appropriate to publically tell others what they should do with their donations.

[Anonymous]

very thanks for article

[Anonymous]

Thank you for good job

دردشة الشلة

شات الشلة

[Anonymous]

شات روحي تحبك

شات عبير

[Anonymous]

شات كازانوفا

شات حبي

[Anonymous]

شات صوتي

دليل

[Anonymous]

يوتيوب

شات كتابي

[Anonymous]

How are you. Very professional site. Keep doing. Help me! I can not find sites on the: disability insurance sales lead. I found only this - discusting colon cleanse. Our web sites. Offer ads thru google or. The hartford svp sean fitzpatrick to lead specialty financial group will continue to lead the middle market insurance segment as he takes. Thank you very much :eek:. Apirka from Iceland.

[Anonymous]

ÿ¥ÿßÿ™ ÿ¨ÿØÿ©

شبكة الود

[Anonymous]

دردشة قلبي

ÿØÿ±ÿØÿ¥ÿ© ŸÇŸÑŸàÿ®

[Anonymous]

شات حبنا

شات كيف

[Anonymous]

buy Bactrim

[Anonymous]

links of london

[Anonymous]

شات روحي تحبك

شات مكتوب

[Anonymous]

tiffany jewellery
ed hardy

[Anonymous]

links of london
abercrombie and fitch

[Anonymous]

very thanks for article!

[Anonymous]

Hello. By learning to discover and value our ordinariness, we nurture a friendliness toward ourselves and the world that is the essence of a healthy soul.
I am from Eritrea and also am speaking English, tell me right I wrote the following sentence: "Kansas city insurance exec will lead insurance group."

Thank :) Discount perfumes and fragrances.

[Anonymous]

شات قلبي

بلوتوث

[Anonymous]

Thanks very much for the compilation!links london
tiffany jewellery

[Anonymous]

Provides the best tiffany jewellery, including Necklaces, Pendants, Bracelets, Earrings, Ringsat the lowest prices.Tiffany jewellery is the best online United Kingdom jewelry stores where you can buy the cheapest Tiffany & Co silver Our huge selection of
tiffany jewelry