I hope someone donates billions to start new universities with professional schools (not liberal arts) at the center and helm.

At least currently, the federal government is doing a particularly bad job of spending its discretionary funds, because the process has been corrupted by politics and cronyism. The Gates foundation, on the other hand, is funding innovative work across the globe and is willing to fund scientific and medical research, for example, that the current federal government will not fund for political reasons. So, I applaud Buffet's donation to the Gates foundation. This is an excellent use of the deduction for charitable gifts.

Judge Posner
I see a possible problem I see with your example with a 40% charitable gift tax with an offsetting reduction in income taxes. You argue that taxpayers would probably be better at spending the money than a charity would. I am not entirely sure that is true. The bottom 40% of Americans, for example, pay no income tax and thus would not benefit from decreased income taxes. Meanwhile, I am guessing that this group is the one that benefits the most from charitable activities. Isn't it possible that the return [in utility] to charitable expenditures is higher than to the expenditures of taxpayers? It seems to me that a dollar does much more for those at the bottom than those at the top. Unless the poorest also share in the rebate you suggest, I think it is at least possible that charities would be more efficient at spending the money.

An interesting argument but I think you overlook some important points.

First of all what the free market optimizes and what we want as a society are different things. The free market will optimize production and efficency while as a society we also value overall happiness and lack of suffering. I suspect that charitable giving turns out to increase total happiness more than comparable spending on personal recreation. This will be true if for no other reason that then relation between money and happiness is sub-linear. Thus it can overall be a societal good to encourage giving as oppossed to buying other goods.

Taxing gifts at a high rate would do just the opposite. It would strongly discourage people from giving as they could buy something for themselves without paying the 40% (the buisness is only taxed on profits not total price). Moreover, the psychological effect is likely to be much stronger than what rationality would dictate. Making charitable gifts tax deductable is a form of moral praise for the people making them thus removing this deduction even in a charity neutral way would have a negative effect.

Additionally imposing such a tax on private charities would encourage people to seek government run programs for their favorite causes. Even though such a program might be totally revenue neutral each particular cause has more of an incentive to have the government do the work rather than encouragin donations which will get taxed at 40%. In other words you increase the benefit for lobbying the government as compared to encouraging private donations.

I think the most efficient use of Buffett's billions is to bequeath it to Richard Posner. I am willing to bet that Richard Posner has no cogent rebuttal to this argument.

W, you make that statement secure in the knowledge that Judge Posner must be somewhat circumspect in his remarks, given his high public duties.

I personally believe that Posner would put Buffett's billions to very efficient use, for example, funding the sorts of scholarly inquiries he has pursued, to his readers' benefit, for several decades.

(I freely admit that I could misjudge Posner, who might truly be a moneygrubber hiding behind a beneficent public facade, but, then, I've read his works, which suggest nothing of the sort.)

Posner has oversimplified the reasons for alumni donations to their alma mater. People often recall their undergraduate days with a great deal of fondness and that affection translates to donation.


If prestige-enhancing motivations dominate donative intent you would expect giving to one's professional or graduate institution would exceed giving to one's undergraduate institution. (Since the prestige of your terminal degree is much more likely to affect your career & income). I suspect the opposite is true. Does anybody have a different sense? Or data?

Posner assumes that a government's income from estate tax on large gifts would automatically reduce income tax for citizens. That's a bold assumption. In any case, it boils down to which of the two parties, government or foundations, are the more effective allocators of capital.

In letters accompanying his bequests, both to the Gates foundation and to the smaller foundations run by his family members, Warren Buffett expressed the hope that the foundations would remain narrowly focused and concentrate their effort on just a few neglected issues.

http://www.berkshirehathaway.com/donate/webdonat.html

If we suppose that there is merit in such concentration of effort, it would tend to be thwarted by Judge Posner's scheme, which would effectively fracture the money between the concerns of a hundred million taxpayers.

Jesse: If prestige-enhancing motivations dominate donative intent you would expect giving to one's professional or graduate institution would exceed giving to one's undergraduate institution.

Anecdote: The largest single gift to an institution of higher education, so far, is Gordon Moore's $600 million given to Caltech, where he got his Ph.D., not to Berkeley where he was an undergraduate.

I do not know if people with advanced degrees are more likely on the whole to give to their undergraduate schools, but if it is true that they are, that might also be explained by the "please let my kid in" theory of alumni giving.

W, you make that statement secure in the knowledge that Judge Posner must be somewhat circumspect in his remarks, given his high public duties.

Thanks for assuming the worst, but I am not Ronald Dworkin, i.e., I bear Richard Posner no ill will. I like the Honorable Judge Posner and his websiteand thought I would bring levity to his life with a delightful joke. But since you have no sense of humor, Jake, I suppose I should reply to the substance, or lack thereof, in your "argument," if the collection of sentences you managed to (drunkenly?) string together can be fairly construed as an argument. There is no reason to believe that Richard Posner lacks self-interest. If you believe that Richard Posner is Mother Teresa, then please explain why he doesn't sit on the 7th Circuit for free and why he didn't donate the proceeds of his many books to charity, Joke. I mean, Jake.

I personally believe that Posner would put Buffett's billions to very efficient use, for example, funding the sorts of scholarly inquiries he has pursued, to his readers' benefit, for several decades.

Like investigating the fashion-sense of lesbians, as he did in Sex and Reason? You're right, Jake, we need more inquiries like that one.

1


mmxq.html

mmxr.html


mmxu.html


mmxw.html


mmxx.html


mqaa.html


mqab.html


mqac.html


mqad.html


mqam.html


mqaq.html


mqar.html


mqau.html


mqaw.html


mqax.html


mqba.html


mqbb.html


mqbc.html


mqbd.html


mqbm.html


mqbq.html


mqbr.html


mqbu.html


mqbw.html


mqbx.html


mqca.html


mqcb.html


mqcc.html


mqcd.html


mqcm.html


mqcq.html


mqcr.html


mqcu.html


mqcw.html


mqcx.html


mqda.html


mqdb.html


mqdc.html


mqdd.html


mqdm.html


mqdr.html


mqdq.html


mqdu.html


mqdw.html


mqdx.html


mqma.html


mqmb.html


mqmc.html


mqmd.html


mqmm.html


mqmq.html


mqmr.html


mqmu.html


mqmw.html


mqmx.html


mqqa.html


mqqb.html


mqqc.html


mqqd.html


mqqm.html


mqqq.html


mqqr.html


mqqw.html


mqqu.html


mqqx.html


mqra.html


mqrb.html


mqrc.html


mqrd.html


mqrm.html


mqrq.html


mqrr.html


mqru.html


mqrw.html


mqrx.html


mqua.html


mqub.html


mquc.html


mqud.html


mqum.html


mquq.html


mqur.html


mquu.html


mquw.html


mqux.html


mqwa.html


mqwb.html


mqwc.html


mqwd.html


mqwm.html


mqwq.html


mqwr.html


mqwu.html


mqww.html


mqwx.html


mqxa.html


mqxb.html


mqxc.html


mqxx.html


mraa.html


mrab.html


mrac.html


mrad.html


mram.html


mraq.html


mrar.html


mrau.html


mraw.html


mrax.html


mrba.html


mrbb.html


mrbc.html


mrbd.html


mrbm.html


mrbq.html


mrbr.html


mrbu.html


mrbw.html


mrbx.html


mrca.html


mrcb.html


mrcc.html


mrcd.html


mrcm.html


mrcq.html


mrcr.html


mrcu.html


mrcw.html


mrcx.html


mrda.html


mrdb.html


mrdc.html


mrdd.html


mrdm.html


mrdq.html


mrdr.html


mrdu.html


mrdw.html


mrdx.html


mrma.html


mrmb.html


mrmc.html


mrmd.html


mrmm.html


mrmq.html


mrmr.html


mrmu.html


mrmw.html


mrmx.html


mrqa.html


mrqb.html


mrqc.html


mrqd.html


mrqm.html


mrqq.html


mrqr.html


mrqu.html


mrqw.html


mrqx.html


mrra.html


mrrb.html


mrrc.html


mrrd.html


mrrm.html


mrrq.html


mrrr.html


mrru.html


mrrw.html


mrrx.html


mrua.html


mrub.html


mruc.html


mrud.html


mrum.html


mruq.html


mrur.html


mruu.html


mruw.html


mrux.html


mrwa.html


mrwb.html


mrwc.html


mrwd.html


mrwm.html


mrwq.html


mrwr.html


mrww.html


mrwu.html


mrwx.html


mrxa.html


mrxb.html


mrxc.html


mrxd.html


mrxm.html


mrxq.html


mrxr.html


mrxu.html


mrxw.html


mrxx.html


muaa.html


muab.html


muac.html


muad.html


muam.html


muaq.html

muaq.html

www.swf


muar.html


muau.html


muaw.html


muax.html


muba.html


mubb.html


mubc.html


mubd.html


mubm.html


mubq.html


mubr.html


mubu.html


mubw.html


muca.html


mubx.html


mucb.html


mucc.html


mucd.html


mucm.html


mucq.html


mucr.html


mucu.html


mucw.html


mucx.html


muda.html


mudb.html


mudc.html


mudd.html


mudm.html


mudq.html


mudr.html


mudu.html


mudw.html


mudx.html


muma.html


mumb.html


mumc.html


mumd.html


mumm.html


mumq.html


mumr.html


mumu.html


mumw.html


mumx.html


muqa.html


muqb.html


muqc.html


muqd.html


muqm.html


muqq.html


muqr.html


muqu.html


muqw.html


muqx.html


mura.html


murb.html


murc.html


murd.html


murm.html


murq.html


murr.html


muru.html


murw.html


murx.html


muua.html


muub.html


muuc.html


muud.html


muum.html


muuq.html


muuu.html


muur.html


muuw.html


muux.html


muwa.html


muwb.html


muwc.html


muwd.html


muwm.html


muwq.html


muwr.html


muwu.html


muww.html


muwx.html


muxa.html


muxb.html


muxc.html


muxd.html


muxm.html


muxq.html


muxr.html


muxx.html


mwaa.html


mwab.html


mwac.html


mwad.html


mwam.html


mwaq.html


mwar.html


mwau.html


mwaw.html


mwax.html


mwba.html


mwbb.html


mwbc.html


mwbd.html


mwbm.html


mwbq.html


mwbr.html


mwbu.html


mwbw.html


mwbx.html


mwca.html


mwcb.html


mwcc.html


mwcm.html


mwcd.html


mwcq.html


mwcr.html


mwcu.html


mwcw.html


mwcx.html


mwda.html


mwdd.html


mwdb.html


mwdc.html


mwdm.html


mwdq.html


mwdr.html


mwdu.html


mwdw.html


mwdx.html


mwma.html


mwmb.html


muxu.html


muxw.html

muxx.html

mwaa.html


mwab.html


mwac.html


mwad.html


mwam.html


mwaq.html


mwar.html


mwau.html


mwaw.html


mwax.html


mwba.html


mwbb.html


mwbc.html


mwbd.html


mwbm.html


mwbq.html


mwbr.html


mwbu.html


mwbw.html


mwbx.html


mwca.html


mwcb.html


mwcc.html


mwcd.html


mwcm.html


mwcq.html


mwcr.html


mwcu.html


mwcw.html


mwcx.html


mwda.html


mwdb.html


mwdc.html


mwdd.html


mwdm.html


mwdq.html


mwdr.html


mwdu.html


mwdw.html


mwdx.html


mwma.html


mwmb.html


mwmc.html


mwmd.html


mwmm.html


mwmq.html


mwmr.html


mwmu.html


mwmw.html


mwmx.html


mwqa.html


mwqb.html


mwqc.html


mwqd.html


mwqm.html


mwqq.html


mwqr.html


mwqu.html


mwqw.html


mwqx.html


mwra.html


mwrb.html


mwrc.html


mwrd.html


mwrq.html


mwrm.html


mwrr.html


mwru.html


mwrw.html


mwrx.html


mwua.html


mwub.html


mwuc.html


mwud.html


mwum.html


mwuq.html


mwur.html


mwuu.html


mwuw.html


mwux.html


mwwa.html


mwwb.html


mwwc.html


mwwd.html


mwwm.html


mwwq.html


mwwr.html


mwwu.html


mwww.html


mwwx.html


mwxa.html


mwxb.html


mwxc.html


mwxd.html


mwxm.html


mwxu.html


mwxw.html


mwxq.html


mwxr.html


mxaa.html


mxab.html


mxac.html


mxad.html


mxam.html


mxaq.html


mxar.html


mxau.html

mxaw.html

mxax.html


mxba.html


mxbb.html


mxbc.html


mxbd.html


mxbm.html


mxbq.html


mxbr.html


mxbu.html


mxbw.html


mxbx.html


mxca.html


mxcb.html


mxcc.html


mxcd.html


mxcm.html


mxcq.html


mxcr.html


mxcu.html


mxcw.html


mxcx.html


mxda.html


mxdb.html


mxdc.html


mxdd.html


mxdm.html


mxdq.html


mxdr.html


mxdu.html


mxdw.html


mxdx.html


mxma.html


mxmb.html


mxmc.html


mxmd.html


mxmm.html


mxmq.html


mxmr.html


mxmu.html


mxmw.html


mxmx.html


mxqa.html


mxqb.html


mxqc.html


mxqd.html


mxqm.html


mxqq.html


mxqr.html


mxqu.html


mxqw.html


mxqx.html


mxra.html


mxrb.html


mxrc.html


mxrd.html


mxrm.html


mxrq.html


mxrr.html


mxru.html


mxrw.html


mxrx.html


mxua.html


mxub.html


mxuc.html


mxud.html


mxum.html


mxuq.html


mxur.html


mxuu.html


mxuw.html


mxux.html


mxwa.html


mxwb.html


mxxr.html


mxxu.html


mxxw.html


mxxx.html


xaaa.html


xaab.html


xaac.html


xaad.html


xaam.html


xaaq.html


xaar.html


xaau.html


xaaw.html


xaax.html


xaba.html


xabb.html


xabc.html


xabd.html


xabm.html


xabq.html


xabr.html


xabu.html


xabw.html


xabx.html


xaca.html


xacb.html


xacc.html


xacd.html


xacm.html


xacq.html


xacr.html


xacu.html


xacw.html


xacx.html


xada.html


xadb.html


xadc.html


xadd.html


xadm.html


xadq.html


xadr.html


xadu.html


xadw.html


xadx.html


xama.html


xamb.html


xamc.html


xamd.html


xamm.html


xamq.html


xamr.html


xamu.html


xamw.html


xamx.html


xaqa.html


xaqb.html


xaqc.html


xaqd.html


xaqm.html


xaqq.html


xaqr.html


xaqu.html


xaqw.html


xaqx.html


xara.html


xarb.html


xarc.html


xard.html


xarm.html


xarq.html


xarr.html


xaru.html


xarw.html


xarx.html


xaua.html


xaub.html


xauc.html


xaud.html


xaum.html


xauq.html


xaur.html


xauu.html


xauw.html


xaux.html


xawa.html


xawb.html


xawc.html


xawd.html


xawm.html


xawq.html


xawr.html


xawu.html


xaww.html


xawx.html


xaxa.html


xaxb.html


xaxc.html


xaxd.html


xaxm.html


xaxq.html


xaxr.html


xaxu.html


xaxw.html


xaxx.html


xbaa.html


xbab.html


xbac.html


xbad.html


xbam.html


xbaq.html


xbar.html


xbau.html


xbaw.html


xbax.html


xbba.html


xbbb.html


xbbc.html


xbbd.html


xbbm.html


xbbq.html


xbbr.html


xbbu.html


xbbw.html


xbbx.html


xbca.html


xbcb.html


xbcc.html


xbcd.html


xbcm.html


xbcq.html


xbcr.html


xbcu.html


xbcx.html


xbcw.html


xbda.html


xbdb.html


xbdc.html


xbdd.html


xbdm.html


xbdq.html


xbdr.html


xbdu.html


xbdw.html


xbdx.html


xbma.html


xbmb.html


xbmc.html


xbmd.html


xbmm.html


xbmq.html


xbmr.html


xbmu.html


xbmw.html


xbmx.html


xbqa.html


xbqb.html


xbqc.html


xbqd.html


xbqm.html


xbqq.html


xbqr.html


xbqu.html


xbqw.html


xbqx.html


xbra.html


xbrb.html


xbrc.html


xbrd.html


xbrm.html


xbrq.html


xbrr.html


xbru.html


xbrw.html


xbrx.html


xbua.html


xbub.html


xbuc.html


xbud.html


xbum.html


xbuq.html


xbur.html


xbuu.html


xbuw.html


xbux.html


xbwa.html


xbwb.html


xbwc.html


xbwd.html


xbwm.html


xbwq.html


xbwr.html


xbwu.html


xbww.html


xbwx.html


xbxa.html


xbxb.html


xbxc.html


xbxd.html


xbxm.html


xbxq.html


xbxr.html


xbxu.html


xbxw.html


xbxx.html


xcaa.html


xcab.html


xcac.html


xcad.html


xcam.html


xcar.html


xcaq.html


xcau.html


xcaw.html


xcax.html


xcba.html


xcbb.html


xcbc.html


xcbd.html


xcbm.html


xcbq.html


xcbr.html


xcbu.html


xcbw.html


xcbx.html


xcca.html


xccb.html


xccc.html


xccd.html


xccm.html


xccq.html


xccr.html


xccu.html


xccw.html


xccx.html


xcda.html


xcdb.html


xcdc.html


xcdd.html


xcdm.html


xcdq.html


xcdr.html


xcdw.html


xcdu.html


xcdx.html


xcma.html


xcmb.html


xcmc.html


xcmd.html


xcmm.html


xcmq.html


xcmr.html


xcmu.html


xcmw.html


xcmx.html


xcqa.html


xcqb.html


xcqc.html


xcqd.html

Just one observation. What's the current deficeit running at, in the trillions category? What's needed is more estate taxes, not less, given the income tax cuts everyone's gotten. That is, if one believes in operating a balanced budget.

Whatever happened to the "tax and spend" Democrats? Have they been replaced by "cut taxes and spend" Republicans. ;)

Hey Verve, What's your malfunction?

Posner made the point that most donations were given to organizations for services that the donor enjoys. I agree with this, and would add that many donations are not entirely voluntary. Some in fact appear to be coerced. Take my daughter's school, a high school, for example. Every few months it would send the parents a newsletter half of which is devoted to listing the names and amounts parents donated to the school. My wife and I donate to the school, we are however among the small donors and often feel inadequate for being listed among those who donate the minimal amount. Had we not been able to donate at all, I know we will feel embarrassed and very concerned. Embarrassed because we appear stingy. Concerned because we worry if the teachers would treat our daughter differently because her parents, who are named, are not as generous as others.

The result is every time we decide the amount to donate, we have to weigh it against not just the benefits to the school that my daugher enjoys, but also the potential level of embarrassment and if the amount's adequacy could adversely affect how my daugher is treated.

Perhaps, by making a big deal about his donation to the Gates foundation, Buffet had the undeclared objective of shaming the third richest man into giving up a portion of his wealth?

I wonder about the precision of Poser's comments about the benefit to the acceptor of a donation due to the tax break. He said:

"The government's matching grant, in the form of a tax break (so if the donor is in the 30 percent bracket, the government in effect pays $3 for every $7 that he donates), reduces the cost of donation: it costs him only $7 to enrich his alma matter by $10."

When an alumnus donates $7 to his alma mater, the university received $7, not $10. The government loses $2.1 tax which it would have received had the donor paid income tax on the $7.

The result is $2.1 less for the government which it could use support other worthy causes, such as defense, build a stronger dam, or to educate and provide healthcare to the children of the poor who may then go on to serve the government such as by fighting wars.

Had the university been a for-profit organization that pays income tax, then it seems to be that Posner's statement would be accurate in that the university would need to make $10 in order to keep $7.

In my view, it is questionable, even objectionable, that the government should lose revenue because of donation to religious organizations and universities. Tax deduction should be allowed only for activities that the government is permitted but unable to support such as diaster relief.

Yong
If a person makes $10 in income in a place with a 30% income tax, that person would normally pay $3 in taxes and keep $7. If instead the person donates all $10 to a charity, the money is not taxed in Judge Posner's scenario. Thus, the charity receives $10, while the person only loses $7 [the amount he would have otherwise kept], and the government loses $3.
Also, I doubt you will find many opponents to the government losing revenue. That is probably the best part of this whole scheme.