No doubt many consumers made mistakes in their credit decisions during the past few years, perhaps especially in the mortgages they chose. It is equally clear that many lenders wish they had never given the mortgages they gave since they lost their shirts by doing so. Does any of this mean that a commission to protect consumers would be a welcome piece of legislation?
I am first of all dubious that consumers would have behaved much better if they had simpler contracts, or had the terms better explained to them. The fundamental problem is that consumers are generalists who must make thousands of decisions in highly different areas. As a result, they rely not only on their own limited knowledge, but also on competition among producers to help protect their interests. When that breaks down, as in the housing bubble, many consumers get hurt, but overall it is an excellent strategy for those who must make so many decisions based on quite limited information.
Even if we agree on the above analysis, some will argue that a consumer "czar" would help protect the interests of consumers who make mistakes that markets fail to correct. For after all, the czar and other members of her commission would be specialists in consumer issues that might enable them to discover and correct consumer mistakes. This type of analysis is behind the "libertarian paternalism" in the book "Nudge" by Cass Sunstein-a former colleague and the present regulatory czar-and Richard Thaler, a colleague at the University of Chicago.
A realistic view of the political process casts strong doubts on whether this is how such a commission would actually operate. Many political decisions are the result of a fierce contest between interest groups with different positions, as we are seeing clearly now in the fight over how health care delivery in the United States should be changed. In these battles, producers, like health insurance companies and doctors in the health care case, are much better organized politically than consumers.
Producers can more easily coordinate their actions politically since they are usually either relatively few in numbers- as with health insurance companies- or they have effective trade associations that push their agendas, as with the farm lobby or the American Medical Association. Moreover, since what gets passed can greatly affect the livelihood of producers, they have a strong financial interest in getting legislation that helps them, or at least does not do much damage.
The emphasis on consumer ignorance and mistakes makes it harder, not easier, for consumers to act as an effective political counterweight to the political power of producers since they supposedly do not fully know their own interests. So I would expect producers, such as issuers of mortgages or credit cards, to be able to manipulate in their own favor any attempt by the Commission to push regulations to help consumers. These advantages that producers gain from regulations have been called the "capture theory" of regulation in the political economy literature. In the case of consumer ignorance, capture by producers of the regulators is even more harmful to consumers since consumer regulations are likely to end up exploiting, rather than combating, this ignorance in order to benefit producers, the way a private monopoly exploits consumer mistakes.
The cigarette settlement with the State Attorney Generals is a good example. Cigarette manufacturers paid billions of dollars to the states based on present and future production, even though they were being penalized for the harmful effects of past smoking. They got a settlement that also taxed potential new cigarette producers, so that cigarette producers were able to raise prices in response to the tax. In fact, prices went up by considerably more than the additional tax per unit. This enabled producers to recoup most of their payments to the state governments. But smokers paid a lot for the settlement through the much higher prices they had to pay. Perhaps that was desirable in order to cut smoking, but producers got off quite cheaply, and the poorer individuals who tend to smoke a lot were hit heavily by the settlement.
I am dubious about this proposed regulatory commission for all the reasons Posner gives. In addition, I have argued that the Commission, whatever the intentions of Congress, the President, and members of the Commission, is likely to end up furthering the interests of mortgage companies, credit card issuers, and other producers at the expense of the very consumers it is supposed to be protecting.
One thing that confuses me about this video and related comments is the suggestion that the audience is 'pre-empting' the pentatonic scale. While they certainly do pre-empt the major third, which is fascinating in itself (and i suspect there are myriad theories as to why this happens, both cultural and physical), all other notes in the pentatonic scale are introduced by Bobby first, before the audience sings them. Therefore, the audience is merely replicating the notes on demand, and in different octave registers, so I fail to see how this demonstration shows the "deep connection between the pentatonic scale and the human brain"
Posted by: coach handbags | 01/10/2011 at 07:50 PM
Genius is one percent inspiration and ninety-nine percent perspiration.
Posted by: supra skytop | 01/17/2011 at 01:49 AM
Great post, I am really enjoying
the process & journey your taking us on.
Posted by: Skin Care Products | 03/17/2011 at 11:05 PM
We are a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community. Your website provided us with valuable information to work on. You have done an impressive job and our whole community will be thankful to you.
Posted by: low back pain | 03/26/2011 at 07:54 AM
broadcasters should now be thinking about to how exploit the opportunities offered
Posted by: Christian Louboutin Boots | 05/05/2011 at 08:39 PM
would like to join your blog anyway so please continue
Posted by: Mens True Religion 5 | 05/26/2011 at 04:19 AM
Wonderful, his trust in his loved ones. Enjoyed very much.
Posted by: bar stools | 06/28/2011 at 08:14 PM
Perhaps if you had done it in the form of a practical joke, it might have worked. I like your Dad for many reasons, both here and stories before.
Posted by: leather sofa | 06/28/2011 at 08:17 PM
This was wonderful. I saw him, heard him, and knew him after reading this. Well done, and congratulations on the EP.
Posted by: jack stands | 06/28/2011 at 08:20 PM
How sad to lose your father when he was so young. I love that you have his sweater to remind you of the great man he was!
Posted by: hydraulic bottle jack | 06/28/2011 at 08:22 PM
Words can't do this fine piece justice - I'd give you one of Linda's hugs if she'd lend me one.
Posted by: booster cable | 06/28/2011 at 08:24 PM
well told, and though he was no outdoorsman, his code of honesty and respect shines in every sentence.
Posted by: shelf hanging organizer | 06/28/2011 at 08:28 PM
But even without knowing all those logical fallacies and inconsistencies—I instinctively realized that entire debate fiasco was a crock of bullshit.
Posted by: glass bottle | 06/28/2011 at 08:29 PM
This article is very interesting, I like it. I will always come to visit after.I would recommend to friends more.
Posted by: mbt walking shoes | 07/05/2011 at 04:31 AM
In the United States, an estimated two million subprime adjustable-rate mortgages are expected to reset higher in the next two years.So a problem in one part of the financial system, such as American subprime mortgages, can quickly become a global issue.
Posted by: fashion handbags store | 07/18/2011 at 03:36 AM
Welcome to Supra Trainers online shop. Here we supply an extensive selection of super-fashion Asics Shoes with different styles and colors. Like Asics Running Shoes, Asics Trainers, Puma First Round and Supra Footwear and so on. Because of the high fashion, unique design and good function, Puma Shoes can make your feet more comfortable and make your life more stylish. So nowadays, Asics Uk Online shop offer the best Asics Running Shoes which are loved by more and more people all over the world. We try our best to make all of you enjoy the top fashion and become the most charming and handsome with the fashional and stylish Puma Shoes. Our mission is to provide the best products and service and also the lowest prices to you. Just enjoy yourself Supra Shoes UK store. Choose your favorite cheap Asics Australia online, just click"Add to cart". Or you can first register for future visit conveniently. As a creatative company, Supra Trainers always gives us more surprise. Order your favorite Puma Running Shoes here, and enjoy high quality, big discount, fast delivery, free shipping and without any sale tax. Don't hesitate! Act right now!
Posted by: Supra Trainers | 08/30/2011 at 02:08 AM
This post is awesome,ecpecting the newest!!!LIKE IT LIKE IT LIKE IT!!!
Posted by: suprayouth | 10/08/2011 at 02:04 PM
Boomers will have to wait another year, until age 66, if they do not want their entitlement checks to be reduced.
Posted by: ohio retirement community | 12/05/2011 at 08:58 AM
The talent of success is nothing more than doing well whatever you do without a thought of time
Posted by: moncler outlet | 12/10/2011 at 07:08 PM
One of these days is none of these days
Posted by: outlet moncler | 12/10/2011 at 07:10 PM
Every horse thinks its own pack heaviest
Posted by: woolrich outlet | 12/10/2011 at 09:01 PM
I want all the stuff about Season 3 and I want no more loan comments! Now-se!
Posted by: Timberland Shoes UK | 03/08/2012 at 05:32 PM
A man can fail many times, but he isn't a failure until he begins to blame somebody else.
Posted by: NBA Hats | 04/13/2012 at 12:56 AM
Legea wants the exposure of having jerseys with its logo shown on TV all over the world. So it is paying for the costs of producing the jerseys and other official attire worn by the North Korean team.
Posted by: wholesale nfl jerseys | 07/09/2012 at 02:35 AM