« Unemployment and Depression--Posner | Main | How Much Should We Care About Government Deficits? Becker »



Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.


Your model does not include credit, and is therefore an irrelevant simplification of the real world. Credit is money, despite the best efforts of your assumptions to assert otherwise.


I agree that from a pure economic indicator, the recession is over. But a double dip is sure to follow sometime next year. The rise in foreclosures and the lack of a credit fairy will stall any REAL output. Companies will not replace workers for some time due to their over capacity from a purely credit driven bubble spanning the past decade if not longer. People may need to upgrade their computers but they won't need one for each room or office desk and the era of the two cars in the driveway will drop down to two bicycle's from free cycle.


Imagine how slight this recession could have been had politicians not been so quick to sacrifice human prosperity on the altar of environmentalism.


"I will not sign a plan that adds one dime to our deficits either now or in the future. Period." Obama

I thought deficit spending was economic stimulus...?


The double-dip comes when taxes go up. Just think kiddies... taxes haven't even gone up yet.... the fun hasn't even started yet.

Enjoy a year of artificial wealth while you can. It feels great - it is just that unemployment is 9.7% and rising.

Inflation + Taxation = STAGFLATION


Professor Becker,

With all due respect, we are nowhere near out of the woods yet. Some data points to consider:

U-6 unemployment for August was 16.5%

Consumer Credit contracted by $21.6 billion in July (10% annualized)

4-5 banks are closing every week and amazingly when they are seized, the examiners are finding the carrying value of many assets 30 to 40% too high (and the FDIC is nearly out of money)

Over 5% of Prime residential mortgages are now either delinquent or in default (second quarter)

Bank loan charge-offs have crossed 2% and possibly 3% in the near future

Cure rates on residential mortgages (delinquent borrowers bringing themselves current) is 6% when just two years ago it was 45%

Distressed housing sales make up 31% of the market

Year-on-year factory orders are off 23%

By virtue of asset backings, agencies purchases and FHA loan programs (The amount of loans the FHA now insures has grown to $560 billion) the government is responsible for 90% of the residential mortgage market

FHA is making loans to borrowers at 97% loan to value and Fannie and Freddie are guaranteeing loans that have loan to values of 125%

Per capita income/debt is the highest its been; ever

The treasuries is issuing 70 billion in securities over the coming months just as the Fed will no longer sop up the extra duration coming into the system: MBS securities already marked at insanely high valuations are now going to worth even less

The commercial real estate market is imploding and their corresponding derivative asset values are melting on bank books

Banks still retain nearly a trillion dollars in "toxic assets" that have not been marked to par and are being classified as "held to maturity." Their valuations are not borderline criminal; they are

Maiden Lane and the other legacy assets (1 trillion +) are crushing the Fed's balance sheet. Their solvency and ability to buy treasuries almost entirely predicates on their paying of interest on "excess reserves." Save a printing press, the Fed is insolvent

Without explicit backing of the commercial paper market through TALF and the other host of short term lending guarantees, there is no short term paper market


How much longer can we perpetuate this consumer debt bubble, the Fed's inflationary measures and the fiscal irresponsibility before investors and nations stop borrowing from us?

Look at the debt/credit situation and reassess your perspective.


This analysis is the "Classic" and oft used analysis of past "Recessions" and "Recessionary Recoveries". This same approach is what led to the current Economic Crisis when all of the "experts"
were caught with their proverbial "pants down" and the collapse rolled through the World's Economies like a wildfire out of control.

Hopefully, it is correct and the Economic Crisis (i.e. wildfire due to systemic volatility) is under control and on the mend. But given the recent past history of the "classical" approaches to Economics, both Micro and Macro and it's recent spectacular failures, I've got my doubts.

"Time to think anew and act anew." - not too mention, developing a more accurate and realistic Economic Model and method of analysis so we don't repeat this debacle. Now or in the future.


This is the Classic mode of analysis to explaining "Recession" and "Recessionary Recovery". The problem arises with our developed Economic Models, both Micro and Macro, and modes of analysis. Such that, the current Economic Crisis, is the result of a spectacular failure of that Economic Model and mode of analysis; that burned much as flash-wild fire would, burning through the World's Economies, both Micro and Macro, at an unprecedented speed due to the new and erronously developed systemic volatility that now exists in the Micro/Macro Economic Order. Catching many of the experts with their proverbial "pants down". Aggravating the collapse.

Hopefully, this Classical Method of analysis holds true and this "Recession" is on the road to recovery. But, I have my doubts.

"It's time to think anew and act anew" and develop more accurate Economic Models and Modes of Analysis that accurately reflect the true natue of Economics, Micro and Macro, and allows us to develop the tools necessary to deal with such Economic Crises now and in the future. So that we do not have to patch up such debacles as we now have to with this current Crisis.


I´m affraid the financial mess is not resolved. The credit to private sectors is falling. The credit to Government is growing handsomely, at an annual 28%. Crowding out?
Your analysis on productivity is very interesting, and would be truthfull, only if the finances were on the verge of some normality; They were not. I´m affraid that there will be a second fall, because the banks are plenty of bad assets, whereas the Government will monopolised the financial ressources.


Productivity is increasing because the are fewer employees doing the same work. Wait until revenues fall further and you will see productivity fall once again.

The "rescession" may be coming to an end but so what? The United States is in deep and permanent trouble. The birth rate is barely at replacement, the dollar is losing it's value and it's reserve status. Protectionism is rearing it's ugly head which under direction from unions will lead to overwhelming inflation. 50% of the population is supporting the other 50%. Social Security is a giant Ponzi scheme (maybe that is where Madoff got his ideas), Medicare, Medicaid and the feds in general are broke but continuing to print, borrow and spend. Our creditors are getting nervous and looking to other reserve currencies and debt instruments.

I am so glad that the "recession" is nearly over. Now maybe we will be able to see the reality of falling real wages, a declining living standard and social and political chaos.

Check out Rome in 400 A.D. and France under Louis XVI.


Productivity is increasing because the are fewer employees doing the same work. Wait until revenues fall further and you will see productivity fall once again.


We are not out of the woods yet. The GDP figures are merely a proxy for employment, and are a rather weak proxy at that. When our nation reduces imports, GDP rises; is this a measure of gains to employees? When the government spends more money, GDP rises. In short, the proxy has been stimulated, but it's not real. Doctor says, you have a fever. I know exactly how to fix that. Doc sticks thermometer in a water bath, checks reading. Ah! Problem solved!

Unemployment is still rising. Those who are employed have taken pay cuts. My employer stopped 401k matching; issued no bonuses and no raises this year. My son in law has had two unpaid weeks this year. Many other firms are doing the same. People are effectively taking 10% pay cuts. These are not recorded in the statistics. Federal revenues will be down for 2009, you can bank on it. Other comments have tilled this ground thoroughly - in short, we still have major issues.

There is a rising appreciation on Main Street of the Austrian School of economics. Since the Federal Reserve - as reported by Huffington Post - has basically rented the entire economics profession, this school is little known among academia, but it might be real smart to dust off your Mises, Hayek, and Rothboard, and grab a copy of Woods' Meltdown.


Just love
ugg boots,thanks!!


I know that your article makes sense, but because of the livelihood of release I had to come here to spam, I hope you can forgive me. thank you. Expect you to write better articles..maybe you will like this if you are fashion.
ugg boots

oil paintings

Excellent read, I just passed this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on that. And he actually bought me lunch because I found it for hi

Cheap Louis Vuitton

Let Plato be your friend, and Aristotle, but more let your friend be truth#.

air jordan

Her advice to me was to work harder!!

thesis writing service

The size and overall looks of this article may seem confusing and not really encouraging.. But I don't regret a smallest bit that I read it till the end. I found a lot of info that is very interesting and useful for the research I'm doing now

coach bags

Um...like the style of your writing.

back pain

We are a group of volunteers and starting a new scheme in our community. Your website provided us with valuable information to work on. You have done an impressive job and our whole community will be thankful to you.

health care

Hey there, You've done an incredible job. I??ll definitely digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I'm sure they'll be benefited from this web site.

Christian Louboutin

ancial crisis - than a couple of previous recessions, such as the one from 1973-75 brought on by the first oil shock, and the one i

Book of Ra

It looks very bad for the United States because the employment growth is now -0.27%.

Paper writing service

Nice post.Thanks for putting such an important issue before our eyes through your blog.Poor growth rate in the employment is a serious problem.Thanks for the post.

Cheap True Religion

One thing that we do is pancakes on Saturday morning - a tradition that we really wanted to do with the kiddos. Is there any chance you have a recipe for pancakes without eggs or milk (tall order...I know). I did find a website that sells box mixes, but since they are already more expensive, and I have to pay shipping, it would be nice if I can find a recipe I can make at home.

The comments to this entry are closed.

Become a Fan

May 2014

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
        1 2 3
4 5 6 7 8 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
18 19 20 21 22 23 24
25 26 27 28 29 30 31