The American War on Drugs is Not Only an American Disaster-Becker

 

 

Perhaps the “war on drugs”, initiated by President Nixon in the 1970s, was worth starting, in part for the reasons Posner gives. I say “perhaps” since I have always been skeptical of the war, particularly in light of the disastrous American experience with prohibition of alcohol between 1920-1933. Whatever one’s views on the initial case for making drugs illegal, the cost has been tremendous, and in many aspects unanticipated. Moreover, and this is the crux of my discussion, the costs of this war go far beyond those estimated in the recent study by Miron and Waldock discussed by Posner.

These authors do a good job of estimating the amount directly spent by the United States in fighting the war on drugs. They calculate about $41 billion is spent on this fight by state and local governments, and by the federal government, through policing efforts, the cost of court personnel and buildings used to try and convict drug offenders, and the cost of the guards and other resources used to imprison those convicting of drug offenses. They also estimate that a similar amount could be raised in tax revenue from “sin” taxes on drug use if that became legal. These estimated direct costs of the war are significant, yet they are regrettably only a small fraction of the total social costs due to the war on drugs.

It is no accident that much of the drug trafficking is found in poorer black and Hispanic neighborhoods since high school dropouts and other low earners are attracted to becoming involved in the drug trade. The result typically is a sizable deterioration in the quality of living in drug-dominated neighborhoods, with residents often terrorized by the drug dealers. No one to my knowledge has estimated the social cost of neighborhood deterioration due to drugs, but it is likely very high. 

Drug prices are much higher than they would be if drugs were legal- probably much more than 100% higher for most drugs- because drug traffickers must be compensated for the risks of going to jail and the violence from being in the drug business. The high prices of drugs tend to reduce drug use, but it also makes life very difficult for anyone who does become a heavy user. Since the cost of maintaining their drug habits and addictions often overwhelm their earnings, many heavy users turn to prostitution and other crimes to get enough money to pay for their drug use.

Most sellers of illegal drugs are high school dropouts who on average do not earn much from their sales, and they also face the risk of jail time. However, they continue selling drugs because their legal opportunities are limited, and also because occasionally a small time seller rises up in the drug organization and makes it big. Legalization of drugs will very likely increase the high school graduation rate because it would reduce these illegal opportunities for dropouts. As a result, drug legalization would radically reduce the numbers of young uneducated persons going into the drug trade, and increase their numbers in better paying legal jobs since they would be better qualified for these jobs. This would be another important indirect benefit from legalizing drugs.

Perhaps, however, the worse results of the American war on drugs are found in its effects on other countries, especially Mexico, Colombia, and other Latin American countries. Mexico is also engaged in a war on drugs, but it is a war almost entirely fought against drugs shipped from Mexico into the United States. The overwhelming majority of drugs that are either produced in Mexico, or that enter Mexico from other countries, are destined for shipment across the border to the United States. The two main drugs shipped from Mexico are marijuana and cocaine, the same two drugs that Miron and Waldock show constitute the vast majority of drugs used by American consumers.

Mexico is engaged in a real war, with advanced military equipment used by the drug gangs; often the gangs have better weapons than the army does. The casualties have been huge: an estimated 30,000 + persons have been killed in recent years as a result of the drug violence, far greater than the combined deaths of American and allied forces in Iraq and Afghanistan. Many of these deaths are of drug cartel members, but a considerable number also are of soldiers and policemen, journalists, and innocent bystanders.

After the drug lords discovered that they are very good at violence and intimidation, they expanded geographically and into other activities. They have spread out from concentration in enclaves near the border or in the West of Mexico into many other areas, including major cities like Monterrey. Some towns have become uninhabitable, as former residents fled from the violence, some entering illegally into the US. Drug lords have taken control in many places of prostitution, gambling, extraction of monies from businesses for “protection” services, and indirectly also various local governments.

Colombia has fought a long and bloody war against its drug cartels that involved many deaths on both sides, including civilian deaths, and a major drain on government resources. A good part of the country had been fully under control of the drug lords. As in Mexico, the drugs produced and refined in Colombia were almost entirely shipped to the United States. Fortunately, the government finally appears to have won the war, at least for the present.

No one has estimated the social cost of American drug policy on Mexico, Colombia, and other countries, but it has to be immense. Perhaps these countries should just allow drugs to be shipped to the US, and put the full burden of stopping these shipments on American enforcement agencies. The American government would protest, but such a result would provide a clearer picture to the American people of the full cost of current policy, including the major costs imposed on other countries. One can hope that then we will get a serious rethinking of the American war on drugs, and some real political movement toward decriminalization and legalization of various drugs.

 

 

 

Comments

[Safe]

Hi, i think that i saw you visited my web site so i came to ??return the favor??.I'm trying to find things to improve my website!I suppose its ok to use a few of your ideas!!

[Christian Louboutins]

roughly the same today that it was three years ago; it “should” be 9 percent higher—which would make GDP almost $1.5 trillion greater today than it is. The economy cannot rejoin the trend line with unemployment as high as it is.
http://www.coach222.com

[treatment of piles]

This is a great article. Wow, so many of these things I never thought of before. I often read posts, even on this site, and I think they are great, but I don’t take the time to leave a comment. I’m going to start leaving more comments for sure.

[chaussures puma]

très bon spot et je reviendrai la prochaine fois.

[Get Life Insurance]

This actually replicates the situation that the UK is noticing too. I believe that in Scotland, the need to look at both sides of the argument is key to defining what the solution should be.

[IVA Advice]

Did you know that a recent survey in Boston showed that 92% of the population of the city may not know the full extent of the problem.

Posts like this help to educate people for sure

[Rosetta Stone]

Drug prices are much higher than they would be if drugs were legal- probably much more than 100% higher for most drugs- because drug traffickers must be compensated for the risks of going to jail and the violence from being in the drug business. The high prices of drugs tend to reduce drug use

[MBT Sale]

Thanks for the cool badgees! When do we find out who the Petties nominees are???

[mbt trainers]

I just realized I'll still be typing next week if I keep talking about the great stuff we've gotten, so I'm going to list it!

[Bridal Gowns]

I hope any dipshit who reads this actually checks there facts because my GOD are you full of shit Becker. I couldnt disagree with you more and understand why you have an uncredited blog. People like you will suffer in the hands of marijuana users who know more on the subject than this fake professor ever would. get a fuckin clue.

[affiliation]

very interesting...

[hochzeit]

Es symbolisiert den reifen und einen neuen Anfang. So wählen Sie einen geeigneten brautkleider für die große Tag ist sehr wichtig. Sweet 16 hochzeitskleider Sie können wählen kurzen Heimkehr abendkleider oder Quinceanera Kleider! Jetzt haben wir mehrere Stile vorzustellen, sie sind sehr schön und eignen sich für diesen großen Tag.

[trust deed scotland]

i agree with some of the comments written here. looks amazing

[crystal gifts]

Wonderful piece! I've definitely had moments of fear of taking both my kids places when I thought they could run off.

[crystal beads]

In my head I'm hearing this on the stage as a spoken-word performance. I would love to hear this at an open mic or poetry slam!! Beautiful. Provocative. Inspiring. Thanks.

[crystal lamp]

It's funny to look at what we decide to ban and what we consider basic freedoms.

[crystal ball]

Brilliant! That sounds like fun - and it sounds like Berlin.

[helping at-risk youth]

Everyone is aware that drugs are affecting the whole world, it can’t be denied. Many adults, young adults, teens and even children are addicted to drugs. We must all fight against drug abuse, substance abuse and chemical dependency. Let us not make this addiction rule the minds of generation. I know we can stop what is happening because we control ourselves and those that are controlled by drugs are those that wish to ruin their lives.

[pas cher ugg]

J’en trouve en Espagne et comme j’y vais au moins une fois tous ans, je m’en procure du frais que je mets en salaison.

Je garde ta recette sous le coude car à la maison on aime les anchois à toutes les sauces.

Mais comme le dit une te des lectrices à défaut de grive on peut remplacer par de la sardine c’est pas pareil, mais bon ça reste frais et iodé.

Je te souhaite un bon we pascal rempli de partage et de douceur.

Je te fais une biz cordiale et éteins mon ordi, je file me faire belle. A mercredi !

PS : Tu ne diras pas à sourire ultrabra itetalentueuxdessommets que presque toutes ses recettes du livre ont été testées, il va me prendre pour une fan allumée (faut dire que quant j’aime, je ne compte pas) allez je file.

[Manuel]

It's not just the drugs, its also the cost of mental health treatment for the addiction to harder drugs. Really, addicts need help breaking the cycle (ref: http://www.brookhavenhospital.com/addiction-treatment/), which might be more expensive than having to address the influx of harder drugs from outside the country.

[juicy couture charms]

Hello, I discovered your blog page in a new directory of blogs. I will not understand how your blog arrived up, must have been a typo, Your blog page looks very good. Have a good day

[sellairmax2012]

Men Nike Air Max LTD Shoes Black

Men Nike Air Max LTD Shoes Black
Men Nike Air Max LTD Shoes Black
But when it comes to getting those pet furs, a pet vacuum cleaner would be a perfect fit. Men Nike Air Max LTD Shoes Black. Different people prefer different lures, lines, flies, leaders, hooks, weights, reels and rods. Laser printers in the less-than-300 dollar niche don't normally have the sort of array of features that this Brother has.. Of course this is a good service if you do not have the time to rifle through endless county records. Men Nike Air Max LTD Shoes Black. he Pens Like all of their products, Cross fountain pens are truly masterpieces, revealing several features that add value to the instruments. There are other ways to find good antique tea sets and other tea items at wholesale prices. Nike Air Max 2012.

Article Source: http://www.sellairmax2012.com/

[sellairmax2012]

Nike Air Max 2009 Womens Mesh Shoes Gery Pink

Nike Air Max 2009 Womens Mesh Shoes Gery Pink
Nike Air Max 2009 Womens Mesh Shoes Gery Pink
No matter what it may be, the Orion Cooker will do the same fine job for you too.. Nike Air Max 2012. You can get this case in different colors like black, red, yellow, blue, pink and so on and you can select according to your choice. Nike Air Max 2009 Womens Mesh Shoes Gery Pink. Bar stools are seats that are specifically designed for seating in public houses and bars. Definitely an inconvenience. Nike Air Max 2009 Womens Mesh Shoes Gery Pink. The most basic materials used on systems are: plastic, polycarbonate, acrylic, and glass. It might be shocking to you but it is true.

Article Source: http://www.sellairmax2012.com/