In discussing inequality of income and wealth (I’ll use “inequality” to cover both) one could focus on inequality between countries—rich countries versus poor countries—or on inequality of wealth within countries. The two inequalities could change at different rates, even in different directions. I will focus, as does Becker, on inequality within countries.
As he points out, it has grown. This seems to be the result of four forces: (1) a trend away from redistribution—that is, from policies designed to equalize after-tax incomes by combining heavy income taxation with subsidies for poor people; (2) greater competitiveness, in part because of deregulation, more rapid innovation, freer international trade, and a decline in discrimination; (3) the growth in the size of markets (this is related to freer international trade), which increases the returns to excellence and innovation; and (4) an increasing return to IQ because of the changing character of production. The first three points are related to the collapse of communism and the failure of collectivist policies in noncommunist countries (notably the failure of regulation in the United States in the 1970s and the ossification of labor unions despite government support), and the last to the decline of manual labor relative to brain work as economic activity becomes increasingly automated as a result of technological progress. Most commentators on inequality would reword (4) as an increasing return to higher education, but it is very difficult to gauge the value added of a higher education, especially the economic value. Think of such college dropouts as Bill Gates, Steve Jobs, and Mark Zuckerberg. Higher education is indispensable for persons who want to be members of professions, and doubtless helpful for most people who want to go into business, but it will not make up for deficiencies in IQ.
Compare two people, A and B. A does not go to college, and his lifetime earnings are $1 million. B goes to college, and his lifetime earnings are $2 million. In gauging the value added by a college education, one has to control for, among other things, difference in both cognitive and noncognitive abilities (IQ illustrating the first, ability to apply oneself to a task the second). The point is not that B didn’t derive a benefit from college. Maybe without college his lifetime earnings would have been only $1 million too. But maybe if A had gone to college, his lifetime earnings would still be only $1 million because he wasn't smart enough, or motivated enough, to derive any benefit from college. The University of Chicago economist James Heckman may well be right that the only hope for many Bs is early childhood intervention.
Thus the question is whether today in America everyone who can benefit from a college education gets a college education. If so, increasing college enrollments would not reduce inequality, though school reform at the high school and elementary school levels might increase the number of persons who can benefit from a college education, although Heckman’s research provides a basis for skepticism.
Inequality is self-limiting to a degree; if it generates tremendous envy and resentment, the government will be under irresistible pressure to adopt redistributive policies. (Equality is likewise self-limiting: too much, and it destroys incentives.) Oddly, increased inequality in the United States has not generated much envy or resentment. The principal opponents of inequality are upper-middle-class liberals rather than poor or lower-middle-class people, and they failed to obtain a rescission of the Bush tax cuts for high-income taxpayers. Obama’s health care reform is the only major redistributive measure adopted in the United States in recent times, and its major redistributive component is an expansion in Medicaid, which the states (which pay half the cost of Medicaid) are busily trying to undermine by reducing the medical treatments for which Medicaid will reimburse providers of health care.
If I am correct that inequality is not influencing public policy in the United States—is just not a political issue—then I don’t think there is an inequality “problem.” There is just the facts that in the United States a small fraction of the population has an enormous share of the nation’s income and wealth and, at the other end of the income distribution, there are many very poor people. Are the rich a “problem”? I don’t think so. All their money is either spent on consumption or invested, and either way it is economically productive; it’s not as if the rich hoarded their wealth in the form of gold bars. The rich influence elections by their campaign contributions, but they would have the same influence with much less money, because it is not the absolute level of a rich person’s campaign contributions that sways elections but the level relative to contributions by other rich persons supporting competing candidates.
Warren Buffett warns that without stiff inheritance taxes (which the United States does not have), we will find ourselves in the grip of an “entrenched plutocracy” (according to the Economist article that Becker cites). I don’t understand that concern. The heirs of the rich spend their money on consumption or investment, just like their parents; dissipate it rapidly, if they’re dumb; but in any event do not by virtue of having inherited a lot of money block the upward striving of others.
Poverty is a problem, but if the rich are not a problem, then the problem of poverty is not a problem of inequality. It looks like a problem of inequality only because the wealth of the wealthy seems an obvious source of money to alleviate poverty. But it is not that taxing the rich would alleviate poverty, but that taxing the rich and using the tax revenues to raise the incomes of the poor would alleviate poverty. Inequality should be a non-issue in the United States—and to a considerable degree it is.
Rich people pay ever more money for the same exact assets, so their lives don't materially improve, and when credit runs dry, workers in rich countries are completely devastated and scramble for any message that seems good and pure.
Posted by: crowdSPRING | 08/10/2011 at 04:32 AM
The balance of the team’s gears means players must use their playing skills if they hope to be the best and come out on top of the pack!
Posted by: database web development | 08/11/2011 at 04:44 AM
Riots might be less common here because of the social and spatial distancing that protects people from marauders but also prevents people from forming organic communities with any semblance of a common social life that Europe continues to enjoy--at least for now.
Posted by: Discount Herve Leger | 08/15/2011 at 04:43 AM
When is actually the actual i phone 5 ( or the successor of the iphone4) expected to be released? I personally lost my iPhone 3GS a couple of weeks ago, and I was thinking about if I must obtain the iphone4 now or wait for the apple iphone 5... In addition, I heard the i phone 4's display shatters very easily in case you fall it w/o in a situation. Can be that accurate?
Posted by: Discount Herve Leger | 08/15/2011 at 04:46 AM
Do you think that paying primary care physicians more will get better ones or do you agree with your recent WSJ article that paying judges more will not get better judges? After all, human nature is human nature.
Posted by: Discount Herve Leger | 08/15/2011 at 04:57 AM
All their money is either spent on consumption or invested, and either way it is economically productive.
Posted by: Bluetooth headset for phone | 08/16/2011 at 03:32 PM
Coast dresses of 2011 summer full of vitality and color. This is your wardrobe an instant update of all those signals through the main trends for the coming occassion dresses 2011. Cheap coast clothing on sale, In order to buy coast dress you must keep yourself aware of the sale events happening in you town or local market. wedding dress which are in fashion may not be in trend in coming season. So the shops, small manufacturer and even designer offer Coast dress Bridal at the end of a season. You can buy it easily.Finding a Coast dress Black Tie Event at discount rate or cheap rate does not mean that the Coast dress Races are of poor quality or it is a defective piece. http://www.coastdress-uk.net/
Posted by: bailey ugg boot | 08/20/2011 at 03:02 AM
well this blog is great i love reading your articles.
Posted by: mbt online | 08/23/2011 at 05:49 AM
Inequality in Income and Wealth - this is the main reason for the downfall of any state or a country.
So,equality in income and wealth must be maintained properly.
Posted by: recycling cell phones | 08/25/2011 at 11:03 PM
Inequality is self-limiting to a degree..It has a lots of content to read..The example of Compare two people, A and B. A does not go to college is good..The article is quiet interesting.
Posted by: PetCareRx Reviews | 09/02/2011 at 08:31 AM
Most of the time, the inequality in Income and Wealth can be pointed to unequal sharing of wealth and unequal opportunity to earn decent income. Acquiring good quality education is a great way to earn decent income but acquiring wealth really needs discipline and insights on how to manage a little money and make it grow in a legal way.
Posted by: Eleazar | Money Making Business Ideas | 09/13/2011 at 09:42 AM
Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same content as you, the internet would be a much better place.
Posted by: ugg boots | 09/16/2011 at 03:47 AM
Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same content as you, the internet would be a much
Posted by: ugg sale | 09/16/2011 at 03:48 AM
Thanks for sharing. This website is to I too have to help. Very good.
Posted by: jordan cool grey | 09/27/2011 at 07:58 AM
Thanks for you post and for the information. Sorry for my english i'm french :)
Posted by: Travaux | 09/30/2011 at 05:37 AM
Merci poru les infos je repasserai
Posted by: Parier en ligne | 09/30/2011 at 05:40 AM
Gleiche urteilen, in denen Jamie Leigh Jones 'Fällen neben dem Mädchen ursprünglichen Arbeitsplatz, von dem sie ebenso wie vergewaltigt betäubt wurde abgelehnt zu zahlen, hat sie gekauft, um $ 145 zu bezahlen, 000 während Richter Kosten dieser besonderen wee, [url=http://www.uggkaufen.net/]Ugg Online[/url] , e. Jones behauptet, deine Frau mit Juli 2004 war in ganz Bagdad vergewaltigt, obwohl sie im Hinblick auf Armee Arbeiter Kellogg Brown & Blattgemüse Underlying angewendet werden (KBR) sowie das Spiel um '07 eingereicht erschienen. Am 8. Juli im kommenden Jahr ging ein neues Gericht Konsens Ihre Freundin gegen KBR halten neben Mitarbeitern Charles Boartz von denen sie unter Drogen gesetzt sowie über ein paar KBR Feuerwehrleute vergewaltigt wurde. Ermitteln Keith Ellison des Ough. VERTISEMENTS. Abschnitt Richter Houston gewährt KBR Anwälte $ 145, 000 in außergerichtlichen Kosten mit dem Versuch, eine geringere Menge an im Vergleich zu $ 2.000.000 KBR Anwälte im Service-Gebühren fragte in einem mit letzten vier Wochen zustimmen, beschrieb die Houston Chronicle., [url=http://www.uggkaufen.net/herren-stiefel-wholesale-26.html]herren stiefel[/url] " Da die KBR Angeklagten die Kosten innerhalb der erzielbaren Gebühren in [Satzung] aufgezählt fallen, das Gericht klar, die KBR den Antrag Gebühren bestimmt sind, müssen angenehme Erleichterung sein ", sagte Ellison.
Posted by: günstige ugg | 10/05/2011 at 10:28 PM
This article is very interesting, I like it. I will always come to visit after.I would recommend to friends more.
Posted by: ring die pellet mill of china | 10/12/2011 at 04:59 AM
There is no good reason why anyone's screaming child should ruin my anniversary dinner at a restaurant you don't go to if you can't afford a sitter.
Posted by: China forehead thermometer manufacturer | 10/19/2011 at 02:35 AM
That's a great idea, Art. She loves dark chocolate. I also bring her flowers, which she adores.
Posted by: China infrared forehead thermometer | 10/19/2011 at 02:36 AM
That's kind of you, Mary. I try not to be too much of a downer and see the humor and joy in life.
Posted by: China infrared ear thermometer | 10/19/2011 at 02:37 AM
Buffy, thanks for those lovely words, a pleasure to have you here. I've only visited, but it's a place I love. I would like to live there if I could so I'm a bit envious.
Posted by: China upper arm blood pressure monitor | 10/19/2011 at 02:37 AM
Kamagra Deutschland. Es gibt auch Frauen die sich nach dem Sex schon gewundert haben wie lange und wie oft der Mann jetzt auf einmal kann und das Penis steht immer noch. Jedenfalls werden diese Frauen sich mit Sicherheit mehr beschweren wenn Sie gar nicht konnen oder aufhoren mussen wenn es richtig zur Sache geht. Testen Sie doch einfach mal eine Bestellung Kamagra und Sie werden sehen dass auch Sie zufrieden sein werden.
kamagra kaufen. Fur wen ist Kamagra genau das richtige?
. Kamagra gehort zu solchen Medikamenten. Es ist absolut identisch mit der Struktur zu bekannten Viagra, das kostet aber deutlich billiger. Kamagra ist in der gleichen Dosierung, wie Viagra, zugefuhrt und wie empfohlen, es wird 1 Stunde vor einer geplanten sexuellen Aktivitat eingenommen. Das Medikament bietet eine starke und lange Erektion fur 6 Stunden an.
potenzmittel deutschland, Kamagra ist das bekannteste Generikum von Viagra (das hei?t, die beiden Medikamente haben denselben Wirkstoff, und namlich Sildenafil). Obwohl das Praparat relativ jung ist, genie?t es schon einen guten Ruf auf dem europaischen Markt. Kamagra hat vielen Mannern geholfen, Potenzprobleme zu besiegen.
potenzmittel levitra online, Kamagra ist das bekannteste Generikum von Viagra (das hei?t, die beiden Medikamente haben denselben Wirkstoff, und namlich Sildenafil). Obwohl das Praparat relativ jung ist, genie?t es schon einen guten Ruf auf dem europaischen Markt. Kamagra hat vielen Mannern geholfen, Potenzprobleme zu besiegen.
, kamagra tablettenKamagra ist das bekannteste Generikum von Viagra (das hei?t, die beiden Medikamente haben denselben Wirkstoff, und namlich Sildenafil). Obwohl das Praparat relativ jung ist, genie?t es schon einen guten Ruf auf dem europaischen Markt. Kamagra hat vielen Mannern geholfen, Potenzprobleme zu besiegen.
http://trymay.com.ua/user/spimmenna/
http://beiruthotels-eg.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=5629
http://www.mediawick.com/user/resfoorsCob/
http://music.invlad.ru/user/Gremsteessy/
http://pandemicpreventionstore.com/phpBB3/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=5822
http://vziaka.com/user/HautGoort/
http://forum.xoxloma.net/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=2811
http://www.chat.krkouni.cz/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=6475
http://www.bbbdfredura.co.cc/user/AllomNawNor/
http://mercadodivisas.net/foros/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=36436
Posted by: rournarry | 10/26/2011 at 03:00 AM
Kamagra Deutschland. Es gibt auch Frauen die sich nach dem Sex schon gewundert haben wie lange und wie oft der Mann jetzt auf einmal kann und das Penis steht immer noch. Jedenfalls werden diese Frauen sich mit Sicherheit mehr beschweren wenn Sie gar nicht konnen oder aufhoren mussen wenn es richtig zur Sache geht. Testen Sie doch einfach mal eine Bestellung Kamagra und Sie werden sehen dass auch Sie zufrieden sein werden.
kamagra kaufen. Fur wen ist Kamagra genau das richtige?
. Kamagra gehort zu solchen Medikamenten. Es ist absolut identisch mit der Struktur zu bekannten Viagra, das kostet aber deutlich billiger. Kamagra ist in der gleichen Dosierung, wie Viagra, zugefuhrt und wie empfohlen, es wird 1 Stunde vor einer geplanten sexuellen Aktivitat eingenommen. Das Medikament bietet eine starke und lange Erektion fur 6 Stunden an.
potenzmittel deutschland, Kamagra ist das bekannteste Generikum von Viagra (das hei?t, die beiden Medikamente haben denselben Wirkstoff, und namlich Sildenafil). Obwohl das Praparat relativ jung ist, genie?t es schon einen guten Ruf auf dem europaischen Markt. Kamagra hat vielen Mannern geholfen, Potenzprobleme zu besiegen.
potenzmittel levitra online, Kamagra ist das bekannteste Generikum von Viagra (das hei?t, die beiden Medikamente haben denselben Wirkstoff, und namlich Sildenafil). Obwohl das Praparat relativ jung ist, genie?t es schon einen guten Ruf auf dem europaischen Markt. Kamagra hat vielen Mannern geholfen, Potenzprobleme zu besiegen.
, kamagra tablettenKamagra ist das bekannteste Generikum von Viagra (das hei?t, die beiden Medikamente haben denselben Wirkstoff, und namlich Sildenafil). Obwohl das Praparat relativ jung ist, genie?t es schon einen guten Ruf auf dem europaischen Markt. Kamagra hat vielen Mannern geholfen, Potenzprobleme zu besiegen.
http://trymay.com.ua/user/spimmenna/
http://beiruthotels-eg.com/forum/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=5629
http://www.mediawick.com/user/resfoorsCob/
http://music.invlad.ru/user/Gremsteessy/
http://pandemicpreventionstore.com/phpBB3/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=5822
http://vziaka.com/user/HautGoort/
http://forum.xoxloma.net/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=2811
http://www.chat.krkouni.cz/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=6475
http://www.bbbdfredura.co.cc/user/AllomNawNor/
http://mercadodivisas.net/foros/memberlist.php?mode=viewprofile&u=36436
Posted by: rournarry | 10/26/2011 at 03:00 AM
Viagra 25mg En Dijon, Viagra Pharmacie Nimes, Viagra Pharmacie Marseille, Viagra 50mg En Metz, Le Viagra Est Il En Vente Libre, Acheter Viagra Amiens, Forum Viagra En Ligne, Viagra 25mg, Le Viagra C'Est Quoi, Acheter Viagra Limoges, Forum Viagra En Ligne, Viagra 100mg En Marseille, Viagra 50mg En Reims, Viagra En Ligne En Limoges, Viagra Pharmacie Clermont-Ferrand, Comment Acheter Du Viagra, Viagra 100mg En Toulon, Viagra 100mg En Angers, Viagra 25mg En Le Mans, Viagra 25mg En Angers, Acheter Viagra Dijon, Acheter Viagra En Ligne En France, Viagra 50mg En Nice, Acheter Viagra Le Havre, Viagra 50mg En Lyon, Viagra 50mg En Villeurbanne, Viagra Prix En Aix-En-Provence, Le Viagra Marocain, Viagra Prix En Dijon, Acheter Viagra Metz, Viagra 100mg En Limoges, Comment Acheter Viagra, Acheter Viagra Moins Cher, Acheter Viagra Nancy, Viagra 100mg En Toulon, Viagra Prix En Paris, Comment Utiliser Le Viagra, Acheter Viagra En Espagne, Acheter Viagra En Espagne, Viagra 100mg En Besancon, Viagra Prix En Besancon, Commande Viagra France, Acheter Du Viagra Generique, Viagra 50mg En Saint-Etienne, Viagra 50mg En Paris, Viagra Prix En Grenoble, Acheter Viagra Marseille, Acheter Viagra Au Quebec, Viagra 100mg En Villeurbanne, Acheter Viagra Suisse, Acheter Viagra Caen, Acheter Viagra Tours, Viagra Prix En Le Havre, Generique Viagra Belgique, Comment Utiliser Le Viagra, Viagra Pharmacie Tours, Acheter Du Viagra En Espagne, Acheter Viagra Orleans, Achat De Viagra En Pharmacie, Vente Viagra France, Viagra Prix Pharmacie, Viagra Pharmacie En Ligne, Viagra 50mg En Clermont-Ferrand, Viagra Prix En Toulon, Comment Acheter Viagra, Vente Viagra Belgique, Acheter Viagra Pas Chere, Viagra Pharmacie Tours, Comment Utiliser Le Viagra, Viagra France Ordonnance, Viagra 100mg En Bordeaux, Viagra 50mg En Le Mans, Viagra En Ligne En Le Mans, Viagra 50mg En Metz, Viagra En Ligne En Villeurbanne, Viagra Prix En Grenoble, Acheter Viagra Paris, Le Viagra Prix, Acheter Viagra Aix-En-Provence, Acheter Viagra Belgique, Viagra 25mg En Aix-En-Provence, Acheter Viagra En Ligne, Viagra 100mg En Strasbourg, Viagra 50mg En Nancy, Generique Viagra France, Achat De Viagra En Ligne, Viagra 50mg En Aix-En-Provence, Viagra 100mg En Metz, Viagra Prix En Villeurbanne, Viagra En Ligne En Rouen, Acheter Viagra Original, Viagra Pharmacie Toulouse, Viagra En Ligne France, Viagra En Ligne En Marseille, Viagra Pharmacie Reims, Viagra 25mg En Orleans, Viagra Pharmacie Limoges, Vente Viagra Libre, Viagra 100mg En Dijon, Acheter Du Viagra Pas Cher, Acheter Viagra Lyon, Viagra 50mg En Orleans, Viagra 100mg En Dijon, Viagra 100mg En Lyon, Viagra Pharmacie Villeurbanne, Viagra Prix En Aix-En-Provence, Blague Sur Le Viagra, Prix Viagra En France, Viagra Pharmacie Rouen, Vente Viagra Pharmacie, Viagra 100mg En Marseille, Viagra 50mg En Nice, Acheter Viagra Angers, Viagra Pharmacie Le Mans, Viagra 50mg En Nimes, Viagra 50mg En Toulouse, Vente Viagra Paris, Viagra En Ligne En Lille, Viagra 50mg En Nimes, Prix Viagra 100mg, Viagra 100mg En Besancon, Acheter Du Viagra En Suisse, Acheter Viagra Online, Viagra 50mg En BordeauxViagra 25mg En Caen, Acheter Viagra Veritable, Acheter Viagra En Suisse, Viagra En Ligne En Toulon, Viagra 100mg En Lyon, Acheter Viagra Orleans, Viagra Prix En Grenoble, Viagra En Ligne En Angers, Achat De Viagra Sur Internet, Viagra En Ligne En Le Havre, Prix Viagra 100, Acheter Viagra Au Canada, Acheter Du Viagra Pas Cher, Viagra 25mg En Dijon, Viagra Prix En Nancy, Viagra 100mg En Nancy, Viagra 25 Mg Prix
Posted by: Haumehiesse | 12/10/2011 at 02:18 AM