Abrupt Change of Authoritarian Regimes-Becker

 

 

The Tunisian and Egyptian political eruptions were pretty much totally unexpected by the governments of the United States and of other countries, and by the vast majority of experts on Egypt and the Islamic world. To be sure, experts were aware that the government of say Egypt was not popular among many segments of the population, including The Muslim Brotherhood, most intellectuals, and many members of the growing middle class. However, the timing and speed of the uprising there (and in Tunisia) was rather a complete surprise since Mubarak and Ben Ali were in power for over 20 years, and seemingly in rather complete control.

I was first impressed by the unexpected and speedy nature of the overthrow of authoritarian regimes in 1979 when a combination of religious and leftwing groups forced the Shah of Iran from power. Until very close to the end he looked invulnerable: he seemed to be in full control of a strong and well-equipped army, and had an active and dreaded secret police, the SAVAK, that imprisoned anyone who vocally attacked the government. That the overthrow was unexpected is objectively measured by the stability of the international value of the Iranian currency, the rial, until just a few weeks before the Shah was ousted. Had the overthrow been anticipated, the value of the currency would have plunged as Iranians and others tried to get out of rials into dollars and other hard currencies. The rial did plunge in value shortly after the revolution appeared to be succeeding.

The rapid disintegration of the Soviet Union is another telling example. In 1989 my wife and I took a train from West Berlin through East Germany to go to Warsaw. The customs agents in East Germany were unpleasant, and the East German government headed by Erich Honecker seemed totally in charge. Much to my surprise, less than six months later, close to one million younger men and women were demonstrating in the streets, and the government was soon quickly gone, along with most of the Russian empire.

The unexpected nature and the speed of the overthrow of these and other authoritarian regimes is what is so glaring and challenging to theories of authoritarian rule. Analytically, what happens is that over time such a regime may be shifting in unnoticed ways from stable equilibrium positions, where the government is in rather complete control, to an unstable equilibrium where seemingly small events trigger massive changes, including the ouster of the government. The overthrow of the government may be quick and without much violence, as in the East German and Tunisian cases, or involve considerable violence, as during and especially after, the Iranian revolution.

Such unstable equilibria are sometimes called “tipping points”. This term was first used to describe rapid changes in housing neighborhoods from being mainly white and Christian to “tipping”, and then rapidly becoming mainly black or Jewish. A neighborhood may remain basically say all white until a few black families move in. If more black households move in over time, their fraction may become large enough that many white residents begin to panic, and put their houses up for sale. After that the neighborhood quickly “tips” into becoming a mainly black neighborhood.

The basic underlying reason that authoritarian regimes fall quickly, with or without violence, is that, as Posner emphasizes, they do not have any natural succession process. A strong man like Mubarak would be in power, but as he ages and gets weaker who is to succeed him? His son or confidants? Opposition groups may begin to see opportunities, or the unhappiness and frustration of young people and others may spontaneously erupt into mass demonstrations, as in Egypt, or in Iran after frustration over the outcome of the presidential elections two years ago. Sometimes these demonstrations succeed, as in Tunisia and apparently now in Egypt, and sometimes they fail, as in Iran after those elections, and in the 1989 Tiananmen Square demonstrations in China. 

Will similar demonstrations spread to the rest of the Arab world in North Africa and the Middle East that without exception have non-democratic regimes? Already the Jordanian government and a few others have started to make concessions to the opposition, including giving greater representation to various disaffected groups. I do not know how many of these governments will change radically and speedily. The theory offers little guidance on the timing of major political changes, but I do believe that large changes in this region toward freer elections and greater representation will occur before very long.

The Internet, Facebook and other online social networks, are changing the dynamics of the political landscape in all countries, including Islamic countries. In addition, the middle classes are growing in importance throughout Middle East and North Africa. As a result, these countries will experience the same aspirations for greater freedom of expression and greater representation in the government, as is found in other parts of the world. Eventually, these aspirations will force a conversion of the political institutions of these Islamic countries into something that may not be the same as Western democracies, but will offer more contested elections, greater political and social freedoms, and probably also greater economic freedom.

 

 

 

Comments

[Acne Care]

neighborhood may remain basically say all white until a few black families move in. If more black households move in over time, their fraction may become large enough that many white residents begin to panic, and put their houses up for sale. After that the neighborhood quickly “tips” into becoming a mainly black neighborhood.

[skincare]

In the long run, the unsatisfied ambitions and grievances of the selectorate create an ever-present threat to the stability of the figurehead's administration.

[Max Furniture]

This rial did plunge in value shortly after the revolution appeared to be succeeding.

[health care]

It's perfect time to make some plans for the future and it is time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I wish to suggest you some interesting things or suggestions. Perhaps you can write next articles referring to this article. I desire to read even more things about it!

[Cheap Nike Shox]

EO EO EO EO ....A.M. THE RAIN IS FAILING. YOU ARE TELLING ME YOU ARE SO CONFUSED. YOU CAN'T MAKE UP YOUR MINDS.... HA HA HA HA ......

[Office 2010]

I am the first time on this site and am really enthusiastic about and so many good articles. I think it’s just very good.http://ns4w.org/profile_blogs/qihang03/

[Cheap Jordan Shoes]

The words you need by the people you admire, such as the: Character cannot be developed in ease and quiet. Only through experience of trial and suffering can the soul be strengthened, ambition inspired, and success achieved. College isn't the place to go for ideas. Death is no more than passing from one room into another. But there's a difference for me, you know. Because in that other room I shall be able to see. Everything has its wonders, even darkness and silence, and I learn, whatever state I may be in, therein to be content. Faith is the strength by which a shattered world shall emerge into the light.

[armani watch]

Best wishes to you guys~.

[vuitton outlet]

This post and video made me tear up. I'm so happy for you and your family, and this fandom proves over and over again just how awesome and big-hearted it is

[fake watches]

Awww! *hugs*

[cycling jerseys]

I'm so glad to hear you can keep your house! <3 I'm so so so so SO HAPPY FOR YOU! *hugs*

[replica watches]

You and me both, bb! Thank you!! *hugs*

[polo ralph lauren]

Well… I was very intrigued by this blog. I found this very informative. I look forward to hearing your opinions soon.

[cheap air max]

hey nice post, their is something to learn from this article. best one from my article list. keep up the good job.

[Jordan Shoes]

All are brave when the enemy flies.

[Rosetta Stone]

I was first impressed by the unexpected and speedy nature of the overthrow of authoritarian regimes in 1979 when a combination of religious and leftwing groups forced the Shah of Iran from power. Until very close to the end he looked invulnerable: he seemed to be in full control of a strong and well-equipped army,

[Christian Louboutin]

The Tunisian and Egyptian political eruptions were pretty much totally unexpected by the governments of the United States and of other countries, and by the vast majority of experts on Egypt and the Islamic world. To be sure, experts were aware that the government of say

[MBT Sale]

Thanks for the cool badgees! When do we find out who the Petties nominees are???

[vibram five fingers]

PSGT, I am guessing that most of the West (including you and myself) are uneducated concerning the Muslim Brotherhood. From what I read (not knowing if it is true), they are very religious but also very moderate, no better or worse than the religious right in the US. Not every Muslim governement will make an enemy of the US. Also, as IK and others pointed out, the recent uprising have virtually no backlash aginst the West in them (burning US flags, etc.). Also, unlike the recent case in Iran, no one is claiming that the West is behind these uprisings.

Also, concerning oil, the bigger problem is Peak Oil, not who controls it. If Middle East countries shut off oil to everyone, then they lose money. If they shut it off to just the West, then others will fill that spot. They can direct where THEIR oil goes, not where ALL oil goes – and money talks.

[Discount Herve Leger]

Maybe the knowledge that the debt ceiling could be a dramatic face-off can help the government try to avoid having to raise the debt limit in the future.

[recycling cell phones]

This post is worth reading as it is providing guidance on the timing of major political changes.
I like this topic.

[Lingerie]

Nice post thanks for sharing this article..it help a lot in increasing my knowledge about this

[nike shoes]

Thanks for division this attractive post. There are some points here that I have not hear of earlier than. Perfect!Just keep your work!Once again, thanks for this useful post. This will be very helpful for me.

[jordan cool grey]

Thanks for sharing. This website is to I too have to help. Very good.

[günstige ugg]

Bortz, genau, die noch nie strafrechtlich preislich zu sein schien, bietet verweigert Vergewaltigung Jones und Gegenklage. Ihr Anwalt stellte die Frau über ihre erektile Histo, [url=http://www.uggkaufen.net/]ugg stiefel[/url] , ry und mitgeteilt, welche die Frau Liaison mit Bortz war Konsens. Diese individuelle erwähnte auch die Dame geliefert bekam variieren Art von Varianten, wie mutmaßlichen Vergewaltigung entwickelt. Jones bestritt das Geschlecht wurde einvernehmlich. Innerhalb einer Erklärung erwähnt KBR: "Weil einige unserer Service-Gebühren wurden inhaltliche und Schutzmaßnahmen der Instanz, und seit diesem Gericht entdeckte Jones 'behauptet, möglicherweise nicht mit Vorteil, wir richtig gearbeitet, unsere eigenen Schutz durch das Gesetz zur Wiederherstellung unsere Gebühren, wie wir mit einem solchen Szenario, in dem das Mittel zur Verfügung gestanden hat zu tun hatte. "" Seit dem Jahr 2006, erschien KBR durch, gestellt werden [url=http://www.uggkaufen.net/jimmy-choo-ugg-wholesale-1.html]Jimmy Choo ugg[/url] , keine kontinuierliche Linie einfach durch Jones platziert wird verewigt, während vor dem Congress , innen drücken und zu jeder Zielgruppe wollen Sie zu einer starken Ohr zu, dass die Geschichte bieten. Das Ergebnis in der Jury Tryout zu sehen, dass allein durch die Frau mates beurteilt wird ähnlich Endergebnis werden die Weisen Sie darauf hin Büro wurde während in der