Are There Sizable Benefits From Extending the Lives of the Old and Frail? Becker

 

The federal government subsidizes basic and applied research on both the quality of life and the length of life. An example of research on quality is the efforts to find implantable artificial kidneys that can replace dialysis for persons with severe kidney disease since dialysis is a limited and very confining procedure. Research into finding cures for breast and prostate cancers exemplifies research on extending the length of life. It might seem clear that research on extending the lives of frail persons over say age 80 does not produce much value to these persons or to society, but economic analysis of the “value of life” shows that this conclusion is far from obvious.

The main criterion used to measure benefits from all kinds of medical advances is how much individuals affected by these advances, and society as a whole, would be willing to pay for them. Clearly, reducing the incidence of Alzheimer’s disease, or finding drug substitutes for dialysis, would add great value to  individuals who would have been victimized by Alzheimer’s or would have been on dialysis. As Posner indicates, however, this does not necessarily imply that putting lots of time and money into developing ways to extend the lives of old people is worthwhile, particularly those who are frail.

On the one hand, the health care delivery systems of the United States and of many other rich countries do not seem able to prevent newly developed expensive drugs, costly surgeries, and other medical interventions from being used to prolong the lives by a tiny amount of very sick elderly persons. It might be better if research spent on these kind of medical innovations went instead to improving the quality of life for other elderly persons, or to helping reduce death rates from cancers, cardiovascular diseases, and other major killers.

On the other hand, even old and frail men and women are often willing to pay a lot for rather small improvements in their expected lifespan. Economists have estimated how much individuals must be paid to be willing to work at jobs with higher death rates, to avoid being involved in deadly traffic accidents, or to take on other life-threatening risks. After manipulating these willingness to pay estimates, the conclusion is that the statistical “value of a life year” to a young or a middle aged American is about $120,000. This is far higher than average earnings in any year- about $45,000 for men who work full time- because the value of life estimate includes the value placed on the many hours not spent at work, and on other sources of utility.

The present value of a reduction in the probability of dying now and at each future age would be worth more to younger persons since older individuals have fewer years of life remaining. But is the value of a “life year” also worth less to the old and perhaps frail? The answer to that is less obvious than may seem (the following analysis is based on work in progress, referred to by Posner, by Kevin Murphy, Tomas Philipson, and myself). Presumably, frail elderly people tend to receive less utility from a year of their current life since their lack of health prevents them from greatly enjoying their leisure time and consumption of different goods. However, the utility cost of any time and money they might spend on prolonging their lives is also lower for them. The fundamental measure of the value of a life year is the ratio of the utility gained to this marginal utility spent on prolonging life. This ratio could even be higher for the old and frail than for healthy younger persons.

In addition, since old and frail people have only a short remaining lifetime, the fear of dying, long recognized as of great importance by novelists and philosophers, is more immediate to them than to younger persons. Their fear of dying could make old people quite willing to spend liberally to delay their deaths even by a few months. Finally, as Posner recognizes, the old would be willing to spend most of their wealth to prolong their lives even by a little bit if they value their lives by a lot more than they value any bequests they would leave to children or others.

Of course, Medicare, Medicaid, and employer health insurance distort many health care decisions in the US since sick individuals mainly pay not their own money, but the monies of taxpayers or of other employees. Medicare, for example, presumably leads to too much spending on the very old because the government ends up financing the great majority of this spending. This is an important determinant of the actual spending on the health of the elderly, but I have argued that many of the old and frail would be willing to spend a lot of their own money to prolong their lives even by a small amount.

Comments

[quality-fake-bmw]

i like your blog very much,well done

[woman]

Good food for thought here... Thanks for such an informative article, it's been very useful.

[christian louboutin shoes]

Nice post , thank you for sharing your article. I really enjoyed it.

[kvinnor]

Thanks for such an informative article, it's been very useful.

[منتدى]

very gooooooooooood

[donne russe]

Very nicely written. Really makes think. Thanks.

[Say Green]

that was nice to Read the Article, Thanks for information , Let me follow you on twitter.

[air max 2011]

that was nice to Read the Article, Thanks for information , Let me follow you on twitter.

[air max 2011]

that was nice to Read the Article, Thanks for information , Let me follow you on twitter.hgf

[منتدى]

very goooooooooood

[Coach Purses Outlet]

En slags "det gyldne tårn for børn

[learn Chinese software]

yi ge ai shang lang man de ren

[mujeres]

Thank you, it's been very interestingly.

[Account Deleted]

Thanks for such an informative article, it's been very useful.

[Christian Louboutin]

ion of our new topic on childcare and paid leaves follows after this response. Two of the comments questioned my assertion that President Carter introduced price controls on gasoline that produced long lines. I am right, as shown by the following entry from Wikepedia on the 1979 energy crisis: "In the United States, the Carter administration instituted price controls. This resulted in long lines appearing at the gas stations as they had six years earlier. As the average vehicle of the time consumed between 2-3 liters of gas an hour while idling, it was estimated at the time that Americans wasted up to 150,000 barrels of oil per day idling their engines in the lines at gas stations." To be sure, Nixon introduced various inefficient controls o

[i love you quotes]

Thanks for division this attractive post. There are some points here that I have not hear of earlier than. Once again, thanks for this useful post. This will be very helpful for me.

[russian girls]

Good food for thought here. Thank you very much for the extensive explanation. Very nicely written. Really makes think.

[Polo Ralph Lauren]

Perfect!Just keep your work!Thanks for your nice sharing!

[eBridge advertising]

Economists have estimated how much individuals must be paid to be willing to work at jobs with higher death rates, to avoid being involved in deadly traffic accidents, or to take on other life-threatening risks.

[MBT Sale]

Thanks for the cool badgees! When do we find out who the Petties nominees are???

[FourLeaf]

I was always thinking,if prince charles is just an http://lanlinweddingdresses.blogspot.com fashion dresses , would 19 years old Diana marry him before kowning he has lover. Recently one of her tapes was opened to the public, she said the wedding day was the http://fashionupup.wordpress.com/2011/07/06/the-label-responsible-for-the-navy-dress-worn-by-kate black dresses in her life----“My heart was as quiet as death, I feet as a lamp waiting to be killed.”

[mbt trainers]

I just realized I'll still be typing next week if I keep talking about the great stuff we've gotten, so I'm going to list it!

[Discount Herve Leger]

When is actually the actual i phone 5 ( or the successor of the iphone4) expected to be released? I personally lost my iPhone 3GS a couple of weeks ago, and I was thinking about if I must obtain the iphone4 now or wait for the apple iphone 5... In addition, I heard the i phone 4's display shatters very easily in case you fall it w/o in a situation. Can be that accurate?

[water removal]

The Most Helpful Restoration Service in America - Affordable Services in Your Area - 24/7 Hotline.

[mbt online]

well this blog is great i love reading your articles.