Primary-Care Physicians and the Reform of Health Care—Posner

It’s become a cliché that the United States has long had a shortgage of primary-care physicians (general internists, pediatricians, family physicians, general practitioners) and that this is a factor in the disarray and expense of our health care system. Yet the very idea of a protracted shortage is an anomaly in a capitalist society. A temporary imbalance of demand and supply can produce a shortage, but the shortage should not persist: price will rise to ration the existing supply, and this will both dampen demand and stimulate supply, and the combination will erase the shortage. 

And this would be true of primary-care physicians in an unregulated market for health care. If there were a shortage of such physicians, their fees would rise, and this would reduce the demand for their services; at the same time, their incomes would be higher because of the higher fees, and this would induce more medical students to become primary-care physicians. So the shortage would end. 

There was bound to be a relative decline in primary-care physicians because advances in medical technology increased the value of specialized medicine and so the demand for specialists (surgeons, radiologists, oncologists, cardiologists, urologists, gastroenterologists, neurologists, etc.) relative to primary-care physicians, who are generalists. But those very advances, by increasing the number of possible treatments and and also increasing, in part through better treatments, longevity, increased the demand for primary-care physicians, who “specialize” in diagnosing and treating common ailments, which are the most frequent and become more common as people age. (So primary-care physicians are both substitutes for, and complements to, specialized physicians.) 

Yet instead there seems to be (though reliable statistics are hard to come by) a persisting shortage, now of long standing, of such physicians. A symptom of a shortage is queuing—it indicates that the market price is not clearing the market. There is a great deal of “involuntary” queuing in primary-care medicine, in the form of long unwanted delays in getting an appointment with a primary-care physician and refusals of these physicians to take on new patients. Of course if there is no felt urgency about seeing a doctor, there is no reason not to make appointments well in advance. But apparently difficulty in being able to be seen promptly by a primary-care physician drives many patients to hospital emergency rooms, which are very expensive. 

While the fees charged by primary-care physicians have increased, their income, as well as prestige, relative to specialists has declined (even after adjustment for the fact that the specialists have to undergo longer residencies before they begiin earning real money). As a result, medical students are increasingly attracted to specialties, especially ones such as dermatology, ophthalmology, and urology, which allow for a more comfortable life style because they do not involve frequent medical emergencies. The attraction of specialization is particularly great for male medical students, who tend to have higher earnings goals and a greater desire for prestige than women, so women are becoming an increasing percentage of family-care physicians—and many of them work part time because they want to have children, and time to spend with their children. This reduces the supply of primary medical care. 

The concern with the decline of primary-care medicine has become acute because of the recently enacted health care reform law. By a combination of requiring persons who do not have health insurance to buy it if they can afford to, subsidizing health insurance for people who can’t afford it, and expanding Medicaid eligibility (public health insurance for the poor), the reform is expected within a few years to increase the number of people who have public or private health insurance by more than 30 million, roughly a 20 percent increase in the number of insured. At the same time, a higher proportion of the population will be elderly. So the demand for health care will increase very substantially. Most of that increase could in principle be accommodated by expanding the number of primary-care physicians, especially because a large fraction (no one knows how large) of the currently uninsured population are young and healthy. Young and healthy people get sick, but mostly with ailments that do not require the care of specialists. What young and healthy people mainly need is diagnosis of conditions such as high blood pressure and obesity that are health time bombs, and preventive care and counseling, and both the diagnosis and the care and counseling are services that primary-care physicians provide. The need of children of poor families, and their parents, for pediatric counseling, and of the children themselves for pediatric care, is acute; and most pediatricians are primary-care physicians. Moreover, the extensive follow-up care that people with serious diseases often require can usually be provided by primary-care physicians. 

The health care reform legislation recognizes that the shortage of primary-care physicians will get worse, and that this will reduce the quality and increase the cost of medical care generally, but it doesn’t do much about it. The main thing it does is increase Medicare reimbursement for primary-physician care by 10 percent. The rest (so far as I can judge from the immensely complex legislation and its as yet incomplete regulatory implementation) is subsidizing gimmicks, such as the “medical home,” which is a euphemism for delegating some of the primary care now provided by doctors to nurses. 

The underlying causes of the shortage of primary-care physicians are licensure and third-party payment. I do not think it is a mistake to require that physicians be licensed, rather than allowing anyone to provide medical care, as we allow anyone to dig ditches, wait on tables, or for that matter start a new online business. Patients are in a poor position to evaluate the quality of medical care, and without licensure of physicians would doubtless be highly vulnerable to quacks. But licensure inevitably reduces supply. Primary-care physicians have to spend four years in medical school and then three years as a resident paid little more than a subsistence wage. The number of medical schools is limited, as is the number of residency programs; it has been argued (whether rightly or wrongly I don’t know) that specialists control the approval process for residency programs and use that control to throttle the expansion of primary-care medicine by limiting the number of new residency programs in primary-care medicine. Many U.S. physicians are foreigners trained abroad, which is fine, but we make them jump through loops to be licensed to practice medicine in the United States; the hoops may be justified to ensure that foreign-trained physicians are competent, but make it difficult to make up a physician shortage by recruiting foreign-trainmed physicians. 

Third-party payment is a pervasive feature of American medicine. Why anyone should want health insurance other than “major medical”—that is, insurance against catastrophic medical bills—is a great mystery, as is the fact that Medicare subsidizes routiine health care of upper-middle-class people. Since disease and injury tend to be unpredictable, health insurance smooths costs over time, which is efficient, but a person could achieve that smoothing simply by saving the money that he now pays in health-insurance premiums and investing it to create a fund out of which to pay future health expenses as they occur. 

But we are stuck with third-party payment, and it systematically favors specialists over primary-care physicians, because specialists tend to provide discrete procedures, which are easier for the insurers, whether they are private insurance companies or government, to cost. The care provided by primary-care physicians has, to an extent, an elastic and discretionary quality. If a hypochondriac constantly pesters his primary-care physician with imaginary symptoms, how much of the physician’s time dealing with the pest should be compensated by insurance and at what rate? How long should an annual physical exam take? How much time should the physician spend urging his patients to give up smoking? Wear car seatbelts? Avoid fast foods? 

I wish I had some answers, but I don’t, given the fundamental structure of the American health care system, which is unlikely to change in the foreseeable future. If the shortage of primary-care physicians persists, queues will lengthen, and perhaps care will be rationed in other ways as well.

Comments

[Christian Louboutin]

There will always be people who'll hurt you, so you need to continue trusting, just be careful. Don't waste your time on a man/woman, who isn't willing to waste their time on you.

[Cheap Canada Goose]

A boy will make you think he loves you, but he really doesn't. A girl will make you think she doesn't love you, when she really does.

[roller bearings]

"given the fundamental structure of the American health care system, which is unlikely to change in the foreseeable future. If the shortage of primary-care physicians persists, queues will lengthen, and perhaps care will be rationed in other ways as well."Great words.

[Agent Greenman]

Powerful! Quite a different view from most others. Your arguments are true. The fact is that this issue is very complex and no single single answer can solve the problem. we are dealing with a complex system which is difficult to decrypt. I wish the "white House" could listen to you.
Agent Green man

[newzealand Pandora Charms]

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

[nurofen for children]

It would be inconvenient and strange to have a setup in which basic medical consultation fees are almost at par with advanced surgery. Just supply and demand, folks.

[louboutin chaussures]

How to Say Goodbye? Kidding ha ha!!!!!!!
Thanks for sharing, I will pay attention to you.
By yzi10

[New Era MLB Hats]

I would like to thank you for your nicely written post, its informative and your writing style encouraged me to read it till end. Thanks

[grow taller]

This conclusion is an application of Adam Smith’s famous dictum in the Wealth of Nations that the division of labor is influenced by the extent of the market. Since medical spending per person and in the aggregate is much higher in the United States than other countries, it is no surprise that American specialization is much greater than elsewhere.

[Xxx cartoon porn]

gnzwwcfdlfs.qptofs.cmph, Fast blow jobs, rSREADc, [url=http://freeblowjobhdtube.com/]Hottie blow jobs[/url], CLqiRgw, http://freeblowjobhdtube.com/ Paris hilton blow job, VHfDNLt, New transsexual, SNjHZDS, [url=http://tsevakademi.org/]Transsexuals[/url], XDbdgoD, http://tsevakademi.org/ Transsexual porn pics, dxjwBjV, Monster hentia anime porn, rlknSvc, [url=http://stlazarestallions.com/]Free anime porn games[/url], JQRRXFY, http://stlazarestallions.com/ Gay anime porn free online, IZAdlCy, Alien toon porn, rTEkefs, [url=http://freecartoonpornhdtube.com/]Toon porn clips[/url], WwCmeSe, http://freecartoonpornhdtube.com/ Tube porn toon, FQkZzzo, Ladyboys of britain, plNWrhI, [url=http://freeladyboyshdtube.com/]Big dick ladyboys[/url], fSqCkEN, http://freeladyboyshdtube.com/ Ladyboys getting fucked videos, ocnWkfF, Ncr nancy daniels transsexual fired, SdfIVFM, [url=http://valange-design.com/]Valeria wong transsexuals[/url], YQsgTVN, http://valange-design.com/ New transsexual, ckEWJlD.

[Xxx cartoon porn]

gnzwwcfdlfs.qptofs.cmph, Fast blow jobs, rSREADc, [url=http://freeblowjobhdtube.com/]Hottie blow jobs[/url], CLqiRgw, http://freeblowjobhdtube.com/ Paris hilton blow job, VHfDNLt, New transsexual, SNjHZDS, [url=http://tsevakademi.org/]Transsexuals[/url], XDbdgoD, http://tsevakademi.org/ Transsexual porn pics, dxjwBjV, Monster hentia anime porn, rlknSvc, [url=http://stlazarestallions.com/]Free anime porn games[/url], JQRRXFY, http://stlazarestallions.com/ Gay anime porn free online, IZAdlCy, Alien toon porn, rTEkefs, [url=http://freecartoonpornhdtube.com/]Toon porn clips[/url], WwCmeSe, http://freecartoonpornhdtube.com/ Tube porn toon, FQkZzzo, Ladyboys of britain, plNWrhI, [url=http://freeladyboyshdtube.com/]Big dick ladyboys[/url], fSqCkEN, http://freeladyboyshdtube.com/ Ladyboys getting fucked videos, ocnWkfF, Ncr nancy daniels transsexual fired, SdfIVFM, [url=http://valange-design.com/]Valeria wong transsexuals[/url], YQsgTVN, http://valange-design.com/ New transsexual, ckEWJlD.

[Casino]

gyohncfdlfs.qptofs.cmph, Trading forex day, cqDBNmE, [url=http://baggyspace.com/]Forex exchange[/url], fbSHxha, http://baggyspace.com/ Best trading forex, QYPGYuC, travel insurance quotes online, TOXpHPv, [url=http://cranburybrookfarmparties.com/]best travel insurance[/url], NiYKtzM, http://cranburybrookfarmparties.com/ best travel insurance, aLtjqqD, Les meilleurs casino en ligne, dGntCkJ, [url=http://judinews.com/]Casino no bonus[/url], CrRpuvP, http://judinews.com/ Casino En Ligne, cIhGFEU, Casino En Ligne, PAcbmSS, [url=http://abdulazizalghonamy.com/]Casino[/url], mrNmNik, http://abdulazizalghonamy.com/ Jeux de casino en ligne, ShbvYHr, family travel insurance, kuRLVeb, [url=http://cranberrypromotions.com/]travel insurance quotes online[/url], SoBunmP, http://cranberrypromotions.com/ travel insurance quotes, THWHeep, cheap travel insurance, OXgrTFZ, [url=http://tavel-insurance.com.au/]elderly travel insurance[/url], QRQkffV, http://tavel-insurance.com.au/ cheap travel insurance, TYjTeEr.

[drug rehab Santa Clara County]

I wonder whether a regular health insurance could cover for a drug rehab Santa Clara County entire stay over and treatment. I have looked up for it on some other sources as well and I haven`t exactly figured it out whether some centers cover expenses within the average health insurance. I would assume not, given the things I heard along all this time, but I would really appreciate if someone would shed light on this issue for me.

[Ross Finesmith]

Nice information, many thanks to the author. It is incomprehensible to me now, but in general, the usefulness and significance is overwhelming.

Ross Finesmith

[Dental Implants Cost]

It is very necessary to protect himself. Primary care services are very helpful they take care of peoples like a home. I know about that services because my sister is also a doctor.

[Answerphone services]

Answer United is a nationwide answering service and call center, offering professionally trained agents ready to answer calls 24/7.

[new era hats]

The younger people might not like the idea

[wholesale nfl jerseys]

The jerseys are more than just presents for fans

[biyaku]

シアリスCialisは世界３大精力剤ブラントと呼ばれ、
男性の性生活の品質を高める、腎臓を補って体を鍛えることにできた。
またはこの性能は媚薬、
レビトラ、ベニス増大薬より強い、
いつでも服用後、３６時間内で、セックスができる、セックスがもっと自由に。
シアリス（cialis）は効果的に勃起機能障害を改善することができ、より格別なのはシアリスがほかの勃起機能障害薬に比べ、もっと持続的な薬効をもっている。

[Dr. Stephen Cave]

what is the average change in salery of a specialized physician from before and after the health care bill? This has been asked several times yet not been answered.