The English Riots—Posner

Marches and other peaceful demonstrations are conventional forms of urban political activity in democratic societies. They compensate for the fact that votes do not register the intensity of the voter’s political preferences. Because demonstrating involves a much greater time cost than voting, it provides better evidence of intensity. It also provides the demonstrators with self-expressive utility (people like to express their views, especially publicly) and enables people to meet and form relationships with people having similar views to theirs, so it is a form of social networking. One expects more demonstrations in times of economic distress, because with unemployment and underemployment high, the time cost of demonstrating is reduced, and because distress causes people to want political change urgently, without waiting for the next election, and a demonstration is a kind of voting. 

When a demonstration imposes real costs, as by blocking traffic, and when it becomes violent—becomes a riot—destroying property and sometimes even injuring or killing people, it conveys a stronger political message by demonstrating greater commitment, but it also arouses greater opposition. The most effective demonstration, however, is the peaceful demonstration violently repressed, with demonstrators arrested, prosecuted, injured, or even killed, for that both demonstrates commitment and arouses sympathy. When burning the American flag was a crime, the flag burner demonstrated his commitment by courting arrest and prosecution. After the Supreme Court held that burning the American flag (provided it is your own property) is constitutionally protected activity, flag burning disappeared, as it no longer signaled commitment to whatever cause the flag burner was trying to promote. 

Riots in a democratic society will almost never represent majority opinion, and so it might seem—given their destructive effects—that they would never be effective in changing policy. But that is not true. It may be cheaper to remove the grievance that spurred the riot than to create and administer an effective machinery of repression. So a riot and its repression may be forerunners of reform. Reform in such circumstances is appeasement, and appeasement can beget further violence, as we know from the efforts in the 1930s to appease Hitler, but that is just to add another cost to the calculus of response to riots and other aggressive behavior. 

There is finally to be considered the consumption aspect of riots. Even if the organizers and most—or even all—of the rioters are rioting because of grievances, the rioting may include looting, because the rioters may greatly outnumber the police, making for easy pickings. Moreover, the grievance that sparked the riot may have been over high food prices or other economic hardship, in which case looting might seem a natural or even justifiable component of the riot. But it is unlikely that many riots are motivated by simple thievery. It would be odd for a thief or other criminal to think that a profitable form of criminal activity is organizing a riot, since his share of the loot obtained by rioters would be very small yet his punishment (as ringleader) if he were caught would be great. A riot degenerates into looting even if no economic grievance sparked it because the rioters see opportunities for quick gain or because persons who have no interest in the political goals of the rioters free ride on the opportunities that a riot creates for easy thieving. 

Britain and America are nowadays quite similar in culture, political institutions, economic policies, and racial problems, yet it seems unlikely that we will experience contagion from the recent English riots. We have a large young black urban population that has suffered more in the current economic depression than the rest of the population, so it might seem that conditions are ripe for urban rioting with looting—we have had many such riots in the past. Riots need a spark, but a police killing of a black is a typical spark of an urban race riot (as apparently it was in London), and such killings are not infrequent in the United States. Riots in the Middle East (riots that are depicted in the West as heroic) and in Greece and now England have been well publicized and the human animal is imitative. Social networking facilitates organizing strangers into demonstrations and other mass actions. 

But our long history of race riots—there were serious such riots in northern cities during the Civil War—may have provided a measure of inoculation against them and thus made them less likely to occur nowadays than in England, which until recently had a racially and ethnically homogeneous population. We have learned the importance of such preventive measures as a well-trained, racially heterogeneous police force, and the cultivation of and communication with leaders of urban minority communities. The race riots that followed the assassination of Martin Luther King in 1968 operated as a wake-up call and ever since our domestic security apparatus has been wide awake. It helps that the President is black (actually half black, but unlike the people of many other countries, such as Brazil and South Africa, Americans don’t distinguish mixed from “pure” races). 

England is not, historically at any rate, a nation of immigrants, like the United States, or a forced-assimilation society like France (although France has had difficulty assimilating Muslims and experienced Muslim riots in 2005, about which Becker and I blogged then). It clearly was not prepared for widespread race riots. The police were insufficient in number and not well deployed or commanded and seem to have lacked, or been unwilling to use, anti-riot equipment such as tear gas, water cannons, and rubber bullets. 

The spark that caused the riot was the shooting of a black by police, but the riot that ensued appears to have been dominated by looters (many of them white) hoping to get away with their loot in the confusion of a riot. They seem not to have reckoned with England’s extraordinary network of surveillance cameras, or with the anger of the people (including the Pakistani storekeepers victimized by the looters), which has resulted in many arrests and the swift imposition of substantial prison sentences on the looters and now a movement to evict looters and their families from publicly subsidized housing. The evicted may be more prone to engage in criminal activity, but the hope is that the threat of eviction, and of collective punishment (family members along with the malefactor), will deter more riotous behavior than it encourages.

Comments

[NEH]

tanstaffl, I think you'd better read the fine print on those Descisions, not too mention the dissenting opinions as well (ever heard of "The Rule of Nine"). As for Texas, remember going "Wacko in Waco"? And dare I mention that bizarre "privately organized Miltia" which called itself the "Republic of Texas". Didn't George Bush Jr., while as Governor, have to send out the Texas Rangers (the Governor's private Militia) to clear out that Rats Nest?
I can remember one Ranger comment after debriefing, "Man! Those guys had boobytraps and IEDs all over the place..."

[R.A.]

The best way to avoid race riots is to not become a multi-racial society. It's too late for America, Britain and France, but hopefully others are learning from this experience.

[TANSTAAFL]

"The best way to avoid race riots is to not become a multi-racial society. It's too late for America, Britain and France, but hopefully others are learning from this experience."

Without exploring every implication of that comment, it surely is the case that America is a multi-racial society. As a case in point, consider the race of Americans who can spell, and the alternate race of Americans who cannot. See comment at 10:49 AM.

[Christian Louboutin Outlet]

Do you have a problem with exercise and working out? Hey, no one says it's easy. My suggestion is to hire a coach or find a workout partner who can hold you accountable until it becomes a habit. The same goes for business. If you're not at the level yet where a full-time marketing person is affordable, then find someone who can do it part-time for you OR hire a marketing coach. Whatever you do, make sure those things get done...marketing and exercise...and you'll run the kind of business (and life) that you want!

[True Religion Outlet]

This is very dangerous ground for us to be on, because growing as a disciple, is not about attaining moral perfection. Jesus gave his life, not just his life (cliche reference), but his actual life, so that moral perfection was not the standard we were to be judged by anymore. Discipleship, following Jesus, is all about a journey we go on with Jesus toward restoration and wholeness! So it doesn't matter how old the person on this journey is, they are not to be measured by their moral behaviour, but they are to find their measurement in God against that transformational power of what Jesus did on the cross. If this becomes someone's experience then we will see a life transformed by God.
That is my hope hope, dream and desire for our young people. Not that they are perfect, who can or wants to be perfect? But that they know, experience and exude the transforming presence of God. It is this that can and will make all the difference!

[Jack]

RA??????? Whew! "Race riots?" Is THAT what you "feel" is going on?

If so..........? do recall religion based wars, the Brits and Irish? Germans and Jews?

Anyway......... I'm sure you hold MLK in high regard for finessing the post WWII race problems with the non-violence that continues to this day.

[ETQ Generator]

Part of the problem with the riots was the fact that the police did not react quick enough. If the police force would have enforced the law quicker, the riots probably would not have been this out of control.

[Firmy Warszawa]

This is my favourite blogs, I like this, thanks for author

[Araba.Com]

thank you very good.

http://prefabrik-konut.blogspot.com
http://rize.kralaraba.com
http://oyun.kralaraba.com
http://cartuningg.blogspot.com

[mobile crusher]

I guess they didn't think about cameras just like the recent flash mob in NJ.

[Mitchell T.]

It said that police weren't ready or willing to use anti-riot equipment. Might I suggest shutting down cell phone service in areas. Many of the rioters are getting locations and times for riots via modern day social networking like twitter. If they shut down services temporarily, like the recent BART riots in San Francisco, they might be able to deter the riots.

[Christian Louboutin Sale]

The spark that caused the riot was the shooting of a black by police, but the riot that ensued appears to have been dominated by looters (many of them white) hoping to get away with their loot in the confusion of a riot. They seem not to have reckoned with England’s extraordinary network of surveillance cameras, or with the anger of the people (including the Pakistani storekeepers victimized by the looters), which has resulted in many arrests and the swift imposition of substantial prison sentences on the looters and now a movement to evict looters and their families from publicly subsidized housing. The evicted may be more prone to engage in criminal activity, but the hope is that the threat of eviction, and of collective punishment (family members along with the malefactor), will deter more riotous behavior than it encourages.

[Michael]

Too many lazy socialist in Europe that have been spoiled with Free hospitalization, and all the other freebees they get, Now they want Free housing. The English people should stop paying them for doing nothing and make them go to work otherwise they will continue down the same path until so many are receiving welfare that we will all be in a country like India or other third world nations living off others in mud houses and no running water.

[jerseys]

"The English Riots—Posner " i can't understand !!!

[NorthFaceDiscount]

Nice post. Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful! I’m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post thanks.

[whirlpool baths]

Fernando- I had the same reaction to Posner's non sequitur that the President is "actually half black."

Actually what's the relevance Judge Posner?

[2011 MBT]

The idea that anybody has some sort of obligation to answer every comment strikes me as absurd as claiming that blogs should be disregarded because they have no editors or

[black jacket]

The academic society treasures the life, because of the life when one time, why can wait soon leaves this world only then to feel that the life is short. the academic society looks at the world attentively, because like this only then the seeing clearly person's true self.

[Moncler Outlet]

Hi, I am also new here. Have fun!

[Psycholog]

yes I agree with author blogs, thanks for sharing

[True Religion Outlet]

I just wanted to comment & say keep up the quality work.Thanks a lot for sharing. You have done a brilliant job. Your article is truly relevant to my study at this moment, and I am really happy to read it.

[chi hair straightener sale]

The article is great!

[cheap moncler jackets]

I really appreciate your article, in fact I think you deserve a thumbs up.whyhpIIfBkAwovr

[huaiyiting]

http://www.nikemallchina.com Retail and wholesale NIKE、Adidas's running shoes, soccer shoes, basketball shoes,and so on.

[ugg Ultra Tall 5245]

Hopley die Vorstrafen - zumindest bis zu den zehn Altersklassen zugänglich in der vor kurzem verhaftet, [url=http://www.botasugg2011.com/]uggs[/url] , Landesgericht docket Datenbank - nicht Tag der Welpe zu einem klaren Baby Raubtier. Seine Straftaten sind bereits anfällig für evtl. Break-andenters werden zusammen mit Verstößen. (Er scheint wirklich erfrischend außerhalb des Gefängnisses werden, während der Besitz wurde vor kurzem Inside 06 verurteilt, ein paar wenige Monate für die Invasion bestimmt helfen.) Gericht Verhaftung führen, was genau sie haben kann. Meine Frau und ich nicht die Schuld dieser Leute den Ton aus der Versicherungsschutz., [url=http://www.botasugg2011.com/ugg-classic-mini-5854-boots-wholesale-7.html]UGG Classic Mini 5854 Stiefel[/url] , kann Israel auch im Gegensatz zu der Verschiebung werden, plus Key Ministerpräsident Benjamin Netanyahu bietet erklärte auch sie die UN kommenden richtige Freitag bis Set erhältlich ihres Landes Argumente. Gesandte durch die uns so gut wie die Europäische Union gegenwärtig werden zu halten informiert Sie zusammen mit palästinensischen und israelischen auch Marktführer, so dass Sie haben, können diese Leute auf besondere Ruhe sagt.