The Euro Crisis and Euro Bonds-Becker

After the financial crisis erupted in 2008, continental Europe on the whole appeared to be in better shape than the US. The main reason was that the big EU banks held smaller amounts of questionable mortgage-backed securities than did American (and British) banks. The housing markets in Germany, France, Italy, and most other member countries-Spain and Ireland are two exceptions- had not boomed as much as the American and British markets.

Unfortunately, the apparent more solid position of EU banks has turned out to be an illusion because these banks held large amounts of euro-denominated sovereign debt of Greece, Portugal, Italy, and other economically weak members of the EU. The presumption of EU banks in holdong so much sovereign debt of weak members was that the strong members would not allow defaults on any sovereign debts issued in Euros. This same presumption led the now bankrupt American fund, MF Global Holdings, to bet billions of dollars on the expectation that sovereign debt of all members of the euro-zone would be paid off in full.

This same expectation explains why initially the weaker “Mediterranean” countries were the most eager to join the euro bloc. They anticipated much lower interest costs on their sovereign debt because they expected the strong EU nations to provide a guarantee of their debt. These countries also expected that the Maastricht Treaty and other fiscal rules would prevent their governments from running up large deficits. At first, these expectations were met, as interest rates on the sovereign debt of weaker countries fell to levels not much above that of Germany’s, the strongest member of the EU. The significant fiscal deficits of the weaker EU members did not seem important in a world with booming EU and world economies.

All these expectations crashed with the onset of the Great Recession, and the resulting decline in government revenues, and the retreat by banks and other investors from risky assets. As a result, interest rate spreads between sovereign debt of Germany and France and countries like Greece, Portugal, and Italy have soared, and some direct or indirect default on the sovereign debt of these weak countries seems highly likely- which is why they are being forced to pay higher interest rates on new debt.

What can be done now to prevent a catastrophe in the EU that would plunge Europe into another recession, and hurt badly the world economy as well? I opposed the formation of a common European currency because it did not allow weaker members enough levers to adjust to various idiosyncratic shocks they would inevitably face. This view has turned out to be correct, but a return to separate currencies in the middle of the crisis is likely to be highly disruptive.

At the opposite extreme of a break-up of the euro are proposals for some or all of the sovereign debts of individual member countries to be replaced by euro bonds guaranteed by the EU community as a whole (read mainly Germany and France). One recent idea advanced by Germany’s Council of Economic Experts is to have joint liability for all euro-zone debt above 60% of a country’s GDP, while each country would still have to manage payments on the rest of its debt. Even with high interest rates of 7% or more, weaker countries might be able to manage interest payments on debt equal to 60% of its GDP. Presumably, moreover, these interest rates will fall when the EU is guaranteeing a good portion of the total debt. The EU share of the debt would be paid off over a 25-year time period through tax revenues set aside for this purpose.

In the short run this is likely to reduce significantly the crisis. This is especially so if taxpayers in Germany and elsewhere do not rebel either at the additional taxes they will have to pay to fund the sovereign debts of weak members, or if banks get off lightly despite their risky investments in sovereign debt. In the longer run, this plan for euro bonds backed by joint liability of EU countries would require joint control over issue of debt above the 60% mark since that debt would be the obligation of all euro-zone countries. This would necessarily lead to some type of at least temporary fiscal union regarding sovereign debt issue.

Many have recognized that fiscal union is a necessary part of any long-term solution to maintaining the euro. The euro bond approach set out in the previous paragraph is an indirect way to achieve at least partial fiscal union. It will be helpful in the short run, but I doubt if fiscal union alone will preserve the euro in the long run. Weaker member nations will continue to be stressed by shocks to their economy and to their fiscal balance sheets, with many of these shocks not easy to anticipate in advance. The crisis helps demonstrate that a common currency makes adjustment to individual country shocks far more difficult than when countries can devalue their own currencies. This will continue to be a devastating weakness of the euro unless labor and product markets became much more flexible in the euro-zone, and unless labor mobility across member nations increases greatly.

 

Comments

[replica designer handbags]

Thanks for taking time for sharing this article, it was excellent and very informative. as a first time visitor to your blog I am very impressed. I found a lot of informative stuff in your article. Keep it up. Thank you.

[replica designer handbags]

This really is a excellent post, Ill be back again later on to see other posts that you have on your site.

[Sinful Bikini]

Ralph Lauren Bikini examinee should avoid to use partial, Bikini 2011 difficult and strange uncommon words, Ed Hardy Bikinis avoid to use complex sentences.

[Bikini 2011]

Bikinis 2012 in English solutions, Bikinis Sale should strive to do when peace in Chinese and talking to, Bikinis Online let the examiner feel natural and comfortable.

[Longchamp outlet]

TAT.To add insult to injury,I think the representation of this article is actually superb one.I'm happy I found it though.Thank author for it

[Ray Ban Outlet]

TAT,Nice of me coming here &happy to find a nice article. i was learn a lot from here. where did you come up with the information in this article?That is really amazing. i was learn a lot from here.

[oakley]

Thank you for all of your hard work on this blog http://www.lunettesdesoleilfr.net/lunettes-oakley-c-3.html

[Ralph Lauren Outlet]

Whoa!Left on my site a link to this post.written in a very vivid, using the grammar very well, give us to add a lot of fun.. Really Cool.That is really amazing dear buddy keep it up.

[sac chanel]

A real information. Thank you and I hope you do not mind if I write this post on my site, I will link to this post, thank you http://www.sacscocochanel.com/

[lunettes de soleil]

Here is the correct page for everyone who want to understand this topic. You understand that it is almost difficult to argue with you (not my personal needs ... ha ha). You must put a new spin on a topic has been discussed for a long time. Good things, just excellent! http://www.lunettesdesoleilfr.net/

[casque dr dre detox]

Quite unusual site that is I expected website, very appreciation potential.

[mlbhatson]

As you move the search for rights within the actual court on this matter may still be a little stormy, legal court associated with open thoughts and opinions will be really very clear, rapidly, and the mlb hats outlet ruling may stick around for years, and possibly mlb hats a long time. Spygate happened throughout '07, and yet inspite of getting rid of only 06 regular-season activities inside the four years considering that in addition to located on the sacrificing stop of the year????s Extremely Serving simply by only a number of things, those who dress in tin foil to select from in addition to have faith in grassy knolls continue to refer to Spygate as soon as the Pats drop a vital game.

ting mlb hats for anyone reviewing in your house.Though the labels below are a few of the prospective customers that will, first purpose an additional, this experts merely can????t apparently agree on.

[ray ban outlet]

Your article is really good read.I am glad to see this article, is so beautiful ...

[coach purses outlet]

Your blog really looks beautiful. I'm excited to see such a good article

[ecouteur beats]

This is a great find, very pleased to have had the honor to read your blog, to my great shock, good read, the article is also very good, I hope you can continue to work hard, I will once again come back to focus on your blog .

[casque audio beat]

The blog is very exciting, but the article left me more inspired, great information, I really like the blog player like you, very pleased to have had the honor to read your blog.

[MLB Jerseys]

Stuart and his brother, Phillip, toured the festival in the uniforms they wear at their jobs as surf life-guards -- bright yellow jerseys, red swim trunks, sandals, and red-and-yellow swim caps

[Louis Vuitton Outlet]

Learning does not stop as long as a man live, unless his learning power atrophies because he does not use it.

[mulberry outlet]

He could even hear the stories told in his day, the volcano, at the center of the world.

[cheap ralph lauren]

He established a I named metal ball, and our earth is a very fair representation;

[Nike Air Max]

Thanks for informative and helpful post, obviously in your blog everything is good.If you post informative comments on blogs there is always the chance that actual humans will click through.

[sac chanel pas cher]

These works can be regarded as the dying author reciprocal second desperate efforts, to express their wounds and pain.

[Air Jordan]

I have really happy for this website is providing the different pots. I am very much satisfied by this technology and nice approach is visible in this blog. Thanks a lot for sharing something information in this website.