Is Student Debt Too Great? Becker

 

Students from richer and some middle class families have their college education financed by their parents and other relatives. Students from poorer families may gain a lot from going to college, but they have trouble raising the tuition and financing their living expenses while in college. It is difficult to get outside financing for college education because education becomes part of the individuals with the education, and hence cannot be offered as collateral for commecial loans from banks. Government-sponsored student loans have enabled many students from less privileged backgrounds to finance a college education.

This inability to offer human capital investments- in particular, college education- as collateral for commercial loans on these investment even when the returns are excellent is the fundamental “externality” behind the case for government support of student loans. This externality could justify governmental provision of student loans, although whether the government should guarantee student loans is questionable.

Student loans have increased the supply of young persons who go to college. In a competitive higher education market-which describes the American situation where thousands of colleges compete for students- a greater number of college students induces increases in tuition. However, the increased supply of places for college students moderates the increases in tuition.

The fraction of American students who take out loans from the government or private lenders has increased since the early 1990s to about 65% from under 40% at that time. Outstanding student loans now amount to about $1 trillion. The proximate cause of the increase in student loans has been the sharp rise in tuition at both state and private colleges during this time period.

Although students and their parents complain a lot about the rise in college tuition, since the early 1980s monetary and other benefits from college have risen even faster than tuition and other college costs. As a result, the rate of return on college education in the United States – benefits net of all costs- grew greatly during the past 30 years. The increased net return to college, despite the increase in tuition, explains why a larger, not smaller, fraction of young persons are going to college than did prior to the sustained rise in tuition.

That monetary gains from college increased faster than tuition does not mean that higher tuition and greater student loans are not financial burdens. These loans are still a burden, but it is easier to repay them when college earnings are much higher. According to the NYTimes of May 12, in 2011 the average student loan debt was about $23,000, but 10% owed more than $50,000, and a small percent owed more than $100,000. Since typical graduates of 4-year colleges or from postgraduate studies earn on average over $30,000 per year more than typical high school graduates, these graduates could completely repay a $50,000 student loan in under 2 years from the greater earnings they get from their education. Students who contract debt that exceeds $100, 000 usually have gone to medical, law, or business school, or have received PHD degrees, and they earn far in excess of $30,000 per year more than high school graduates. Hence they too usually can finance their larger student debts without much hardship.

Of course, as Posner indicates, the prolonged recession has hurt the earnings prospects of young college graduates. Many of them need to be given, and are receiving, greater flexibility in repaying their student loans until economic conditions return to more normal levels. Others with student loans do not earn much because they went to bad schools, or they dropped out of school before acquiring much in the way of useable skills, or they went into occupations that do not pay well. Doing away with federal guarantees of student loans would discourage college from trying to foster excessive debt on students with these unpromising economic futures. Moreover, especially if federal guarantees were eliminated, student loans should become dischargeable through personal bankruptcy, the way most other loans are dischargeable.

One might also want to experiment with student loans that are like equities; that is, where the amount to be repaid depends on earnings. These equity-type student loans have their own problems, but they might be a useful complement to the present system where loans are given with fixed rather than effectively variable interest rates.

Young families with mortgages that exceed $100,000 under normal circumstances are not considered to be in dire economic straits, even though their homes can be taken if they fail to meet their mortgage payments, and they are only investing in more comfortable living arrangements. Young couples that contracted a similar level of debt when they were students have invested in raising their earning power, usually by a lot. So I find it difficult to comprehend why sizable mortgages are accepted while there are political and media outcries over comparable student loans that are based on usually highly productive investments in human capital.

 

Comments

[Buy Salwar Kameez Online]

Ha ha, luck is too great, actually let I met such a good article, heart is very happy, I seriously read this article and article really feel is good, the article central thought gripping content, write very exciting.

[Michael Kors]

Thanks for sharing! The fashion Michael Kors UK has constantly been evolving making many brand Michael Kors HandBags more challenging to maintain up with all of the newest Discount Michael Kors styles. As we all know, well-known brand are always popular around the world. And owning a luxury Michael Kors Hamilton seems to be a dream for all the women.
When it comes to 2012 new style Longchamp Bags, somebody would choose get online and find out some latest Longchamp Le Pliage Handbags. There are undoubtedly one of Hollywood’s most favoured Discount Longchamp designers. The unique design Longchamp Hobo Bags attacted numerous of girls.
http://www.michaelkorssaleuk.com/
http://www.longchampsalestore.com/

[Apry]

As long as you've been making ptmyenas on time, you probably shouldn't get credit counselling because it will be a bad mark on your credit. Pick your card or consolidation loan with the highest interest and put all the extra money you can into paying it off, making the minimum payment on everything else. If you get a chunk of money from a tax refund or whatever, put it towards the highest interest card. When you have that one paid off, take what you were paying monthly towards that one, and now use that money to put towards the next card, in ADDITION to what you were already paying the next card. Stay with the minimum ptmyenas on the student loan and the medical bills because they will have the lowest interest, and they don't hurt your credit so much if they're part of your debts. Do research on frugal living and money management to find out exactly where your money is going and tips on how to reduce your day to day spending on food, groceries, and other extra items. Like, you could use cloth diapers because disposables are so expensive. You can make your own baby wipes out of papertowels, baby soap and baby oil and it's WAY cheaper than buying them in the box at the store. You can find all kinds of ways to reduce your spending by finding cheaper alternatives to the things you buy every day or every week.

[Tanja]

I don't think there are any services that will codntlisaoe a student loan with your credit card debt. I have seen where students will take out a bit extra in their loans and pay off their CCs with that, since the student loans are at a cheaper rate, and get even lower when you codntlisaoe them after graduation. You can find debt management services to help you with the CCs, or even get a line of credit with a bank, the rates will typically be 10% lower than most CCs (that's at a high of 23-26% on the CC). Not great, but it still allows your payment to stretch further when paying off the CC. However, debt management services will do exactly what I state in the paragraphs below, when it comes to repayment. So it might be better for you to try it yourself first.You have to understand that CCs, much like loan brokers, are looking to make their money first, so your payments up front will spend more going towards the interest payments than the principle. If you can pay over your minimums, you can pay it off that much faster. And if you have several CCs, start with the one that has the most balance on it, and the highest rate, pay it off first, and pay more than the minimum, then move that amount you were paying on the card to the NEXT, once the first card is paid off. And with your student loans, you can save money on them by taking a graduated payment and consolidating them. However, there are drawbacks to consolidation, you are stuck paying them, you cannot defer or default IIRC. Check out the links below for more advice on this area. I've read most of her books, she's a great financial person.

[kulji007@gmail.com]

I can get into. One thing I just want to say is that your Blog "

[Linda]

if you take out a student loan next sestmeer and use the proceeds to send a payment to your credit card, then the card will be paid. Since loans can be used for living expenses, such as, rent, utilities, fuel, auto maintenence. I used to have friends that took out loans to go on vacation during Spring break. The thing is, your school will take whatever you owe them first then the rest is for you to use for your expenses. Deposit your balance into your checking account; then write a check for your payment. This eliminates one balance, just don't make it a habit to use credit cards for impulse purchases, that is dangerous whether you are in school or not.

[Pikavipit Vippiä]

Most of the poor families are hugging student loan even the interest is really high,now a days there is a lot of student have a very bad debt and it was really high number of them,in Finland most of the people are using loan for some finances some are also using student loan and for them is really helpful that't why their debt is really manage very well.

[Nike Air Yeezy 2]

Maternal love is a ray of sunshine, let your mind even in the cold winter, you can feel as warm as in spring; maternal love is a clear springs, so even if your emotions are still covered with years of dust beneath pure clear.

[mackenzie]

School and I never really got along, but now that I am a little older I was thinking about going back to school. I am just not sure what for. I heard about life experience degrees, that might be something I am interested in. Or I could do something like stenography but I am worried about how much its going to cost. I need to do some more research, thanks for the great information!